Lofgren Shane, Hinchcliff Monique, Carns Mary, Wood Tammara, Aren Kathleen, Arroyo Esperanza, Cheung Peggie, Kuo Alex, Valenzuela Antonia, Haemel Anna, Wolters Paul J, Gordon Jessica, Spiera Robert, Assassi Shervin, Boin Francesco, Chung Lorinda, Fiorentino David, Utz Paul J, Whitfield Michael L, Khatri Purvesh
Institute for Immunity, Transplantation, and Infection.
Division of Biomedical Informatics Research, Department of Medicine, Stanford University, California, USA.
JCI Insight. 2016 Dec 22;1(21):e89073. doi: 10.1172/jci.insight.89073.
Systemic sclerosis (SSc) is a rare autoimmune disease with the highest case-fatality rate of all connective tissue diseases. Current efforts to determine patient response to a given treatment using the modified Rodnan skin score (mRSS) are complicated by interclinician variability, confounding, and the time required between sequential mRSS measurements to observe meaningful change. There is an unmet critical need for an objective metric of SSc disease severity. Here, we performed an integrated, multicohort analysis of SSc transcriptome data across 7 datasets from 6 centers composed of 515 samples. Using 158 skin samples from SSc patients and healthy controls recruited at 2 centers as a discovery cohort, we identified a 415-gene expression signature specific for SSc, and validated its ability to distinguish SSc patients from healthy controls in an additional 357 skin samples from 5 independent cohorts. Next, we defined the SSc skin severity score (4S). In every SSc cohort of skin biopsy samples analyzed in our study, 4S correlated significantly with mRSS, allowing objective quantification of SSc disease severity. Using transcriptome data from the largest longitudinal trial of SSc patients to date, we showed that 4S allowed us to objectively monitor individual SSc patients over time, as (a) the change in 4S of a patient is significantly correlated with change in the mRSS, and (b) the change in 4S at 12 months of treatment could predict the change in mRSS at 24 months. Our results suggest that 4S could be used to distinguish treatment responders from nonresponders prior to mRSS change. Our results demonstrate the potential clinical utility of a novel robust molecular signature and a computational approach to SSc disease severity quantification.
系统性硬化症(SSc)是一种罕见的自身免疫性疾病,在所有结缔组织疾病中病死率最高。目前,使用改良罗德南皮肤评分(mRSS)来确定患者对特定治疗的反应存在诸多问题,包括临床医生之间的差异、混杂因素以及连续测量mRSS以观察有意义变化所需的时间。对于系统性硬化症疾病严重程度的客观指标存在迫切未满足的需求。在此,我们对来自6个中心的7个数据集、共515个样本的系统性硬化症转录组数据进行了综合多队列分析。我们将来自2个中心招募的158例系统性硬化症患者和健康对照的皮肤样本作为发现队列,鉴定出了一种系统性硬化症特异性的415基因表达特征,并在来自5个独立队列的另外357个皮肤样本中验证了其区分系统性硬化症患者和健康对照的能力。接下来,我们定义了系统性硬化症皮肤严重程度评分(4S)。在我们研究中分析的每个系统性硬化症皮肤活检样本队列中,4S与mRSS显著相关,从而能够客观量化系统性硬化症疾病严重程度。利用迄今为止最大规模的系统性硬化症患者纵向试验的转录组数据,我们表明4S使我们能够随时间客观监测个体系统性硬化症患者,因为(a)患者的4S变化与mRSS变化显著相关,并且(b)治疗12个月时的4S变化可以预测24个月时的mRSS变化。我们的结果表明,在mRSS变化之前,4S可用于区分治疗反应者和无反应者。我们的结果证明了一种新型强大分子特征和计算方法在系统性硬化症疾病严重程度量化方面的潜在临床应用价值。