Blakely R L
Department of Anthropology, Georgia State University, Atlanta 30303.
Am J Phys Anthropol. 1989 Oct;80(2):173-85. doi: 10.1002/ajpa.1330800205.
Because plants and animals consume or absorb different amounts of strontium and calcium, anthropologists are able to use strontium/calcium (Sr/Ca) ratios from archaeologically recovered human bone to estimate the relative contributions of meat and plants to paleodiets. Often females exhibit higher Sr/Ca ratios than males, a fact usually attributed to lower meat intake among women. However, in vivo and in vitro experiments with laboratory animals show that pregnancy and lactation elevate maternal bone strontium and depress maternal bone calcium because 1) strontium is discriminated against in favor of calcium in the transport of ions to the placenta and mammary glands and 2) pregnancy and lactation facilitate absorption of alkaline earth metals from the gut. In this study, bone Sr/Ca ratios and strontium concentrations were compared between reproductive-age females, postmenopausal females, and adult males from two late prehistoric Native American sites in Georgia: the King site (N = 43) and the Etowah site (N = 51). At the King site, the mean Sr/Ca ratio of females was over 14% greater than that of males. At Etowah, the mean strontium level of reproductive-age females exceeded that of postmenopausal females by almost 25%. Most of the difference, it is argued, is due to pregnancy and lactation. A dietary preference among pregnant and lactating women for foods high in alkaline earths, particularly nuts and corn, may also be partially responsible. Until we assess the influence variables other than nutrition exert on trace element concentrations, our reconstructions of paleodiets will be suspect.
由于植物和动物摄取或吸收的锶和钙量不同,人类学家能够利用从考古发掘出的人类骨骼中获取的锶/钙(Sr/Ca)比率,来估算肉类和植物在古饮食中的相对占比。通常情况下,女性的Sr/Ca比率高于男性,这一事实通常归因于女性较低的肉类摄入量。然而,对实验动物进行的体内和体外实验表明,怀孕和哺乳期会提高母体骨骼中的锶含量并降低母体骨骼中的钙含量,原因如下:1)在离子向胎盘和乳腺的转运过程中,锶相对于钙处于劣势;2)怀孕和哺乳期会促进肠道对碱土金属的吸收。在本研究中,对来自佐治亚州两个史前晚期美洲原住民遗址(国王遗址,N = 43;埃托瓦遗址,N = 51)的育龄女性、绝经后女性和成年男性的骨骼Sr/Ca比率及锶浓度进行了比较。在国王遗址,女性的平均Sr/Ca比率比男性高出14%以上。在埃托瓦遗址,育龄女性的平均锶含量比绝经后女性高出近25%。有人认为,大部分差异是由怀孕和哺乳期造成的。怀孕和哺乳期女性对富含碱土金属的食物(特别是坚果和玉米)的饮食偏好也可能是部分原因。在我们评估除营养之外的其他变量对微量元素浓度的影响之前,我们对古饮食的重建结果将是可疑的。