Sillen A
Am J Phys Anthropol. 1981 Oct;56(2):131-7. doi: 10.1002/ajpa.1330560204.
Faunal and human bones from the Natufian and Aurignacian levels of Hayonim Cave, Israel, were analyzed for calcium, strontium, and phosphate, in order to investigate the efficacy of strontium measurements for determining the proportion of meat in human diets. This site in the western Galilee was appropriate for a test of the technique since a) herbivore and carnivore fauna were present in numbers from two different time periods, b) well-characterized human skeletons were also present in at least one of these levels, and c) the diets of the individuals examined were basically well understood. On the basis of Sr/Ca values, a large difference was observed between Natufian herbivore bones and carnivore bones in the manner predicted by the diets of these species. Sr/Ca values for the adult humans from the same level fell midway between the herbivore and carnivore ranges. However, a different pattern was observed for Aurignacian fauna; no difference could be found between Sr/Ca ratios of herbivore and carnivore bones. The findings suggest that, in certain circumstances, the technique may provide important new paleodietary information. However, at any given site or level, both herbivore and carnivore fauna should be analyzed before conclusions about human diets are drawn from it.
对以色列哈约尼姆洞穴纳图夫文化层和奥瑞纳文化层的动物骨骼和人类骨骼进行了钙、锶和磷酸盐分析,以研究通过测量锶来确定人类饮食中肉类比例的有效性。位于加利利西部的这个遗址适合对该技术进行测试,原因如下:a) 两个不同时期都有数量可观的食草动物和食肉动物群落;b) 至少在其中一个文化层中也存在特征明确的人类骨骼;c) 所研究个体的饮食基本为人所知。基于锶钙比值,纳图夫文化层的食草动物骨骼和食肉动物骨骼之间存在很大差异,符合这些物种饮食所预测的模式。同一文化层成年人类的锶钙比值落在食草动物和食肉动物范围的中间。然而,奥瑞纳文化层的动物群落呈现出不同的模式;食草动物和食肉动物骨骼的锶钙比值之间没有差异。研究结果表明,在某些情况下,该技术可能会提供重要的新的古饮食信息。然而,在任何给定的遗址或文化层,在根据其得出关于人类饮食的结论之前,都应该对食草动物和食肉动物群落进行分析。