Doret M, Kayem G
Service de gynécologie obstétrique, hospices civils de Lyon, hôpital Femme-Mère-Enfant, 59, boulevard Pinel, 69677 Bron cedex, France.
Département d'obstétrique et gynécologie, hôpital Trousseau, AP-HP, 75012 Paris, France.
J Gynecol Obstet Biol Reprod (Paris). 2016 Dec;45(10):1374-1398. doi: 10.1016/j.jgyn.2016.09.018. Epub 2016 Oct 28.
To propose guidelines for clinical practice for tocolysis in preterm labor without premature preterm rupture of the membranes (PPROM).
Bibliographic searches were performed in the Medline and Cochrane databases and gynecologist and obstetricians' international society guidelines. It is important to note that most studies included women in preterm labour with and without PPROM.
Compared with placebo, tocolytics are not associated with a reduction in neonatal mortality or morbidity (LE2). Compared with betamimetics, nifedipine is associated with a reduction in necrotizing enterocolitis, intraventricular hemorrhage and respiratory distress syndrome (LE2). There is no difference between nifedipine and atosiban regarding neonatal prognosis, except a modest reduction in NICU transfer with nifedipine (LE2). Betamimetics, atosiban and nifedipine are equivalent to prolong pregnancy for more than 48hours (LE2). Compared with betamimetics, nifedipine reduces delivery before 34 WG and is associated with a longer pregnancy (LE2). Atosiban and nifedipine are equivalent to prolong the pregnancy over 7 days (LE2), but in women with spontaneous preterm labour without PPROM, nifedipine reduces deliveries before 37 WG and pregnancy prolongation is longer, without improving neonatal prognosis (LE2). Maternal severe adverse effects may occur with all tocolytics (LE4). Betamimetics cardiovascular adverse effects are frequents (LE2) and may be serious (maternal death) (LE4). Nifedipine and atosiban reduce maternal adverse effect compared with placebo (LE2). Cardiovascular adverse effects are moderately increased with nifedipine compared with atosiban (LE2), without increasing treatment discontinuation (LE2). Regarding their benefits on pregnancy prolongation and good maternal tolerance, atosiban and nifedipine can be used for tocolysis in spontaneous preterm labour without PPROM (Grade B), for singleton and multiple pregnancies (Professional Consensus). Advantageously, nifedipine is orally taken and is inexpensive (Professional Consensus). Nicardipine should not be used for tocolysis (Professional Consensus) and betamimetics should not be prescribed anymore for tocolysis (Grade C). All tocolytic treatment should be prescribed for up to 48hours (Grade B). In case of initial tocolysis failure, another treatment may be proposed with the other class of tocolytic (Professional Consensus). Different class of tocolytics should not be combined (Grade C). Scientific data are lacking to propose guidelines regarding a rescue tocolysis, after a first previous successful tocolysis with complete antenatal corticosteroid therapy (Professional Consensus). There is no scientific evidence to propose a tocolysis in women with advanced dilatation (GradeC), nor prescribe a tocolysis after 34 WG (Professional Consensus). There is no evidence to define a gestational age lower limit for tocolysis (Professional Consensus).
Nifedpine and atosiban can be used for tocolysis (Grade B), including for multiple pregnancies (Professional Consensus). Maintenance tocolysis is useless (Grade C) and potentially harmful (Grade C). Betamimetics should not be used for tocolysis (Professional Consensus).
提出未合并胎膜早破(PPROM)的早产宫缩抑制临床实践指南。
在Medline和Cochrane数据库以及妇产科医生国际协会指南中进行文献检索。需要注意的是,大多数研究纳入了合并和未合并PPROM的早产女性。
与安慰剂相比,宫缩抑制剂与新生儿死亡率或发病率的降低无关(证据水平2)。与β-拟交感神经药相比,硝苯地平与坏死性小肠结肠炎、脑室内出血和呼吸窘迫综合征的减少有关(证据水平2)。硝苯地平和阿托西班在新生儿预后方面无差异,但硝苯地平可使新生儿重症监护病房(NICU)转诊略有减少(证据水平2)。β-拟交感神经药、阿托西班和硝苯地平在延长妊娠48小时以上方面等效(证据水平2)。与β-拟交感神经药相比,硝苯地平可减少34周前的分娩,并与更长的孕周相关(证据水平2)。阿托西班和硝苯地平在延长妊娠7天以上方面等效(证据水平2),但在未合并PPROM的自发性早产女性中,硝苯地平可减少37周前的分娩,且孕周延长更长,但未改善新生儿预后(证据水平2)。所有宫缩抑制剂都可能发生母体严重不良反应(证据水平4)。β-拟交感神经药的心血管不良反应常见(证据水平2),且可能严重(母体死亡)(证据水平4)。与安慰剂相比,硝苯地平和阿托西班可减少母体不良反应(证据水平2)。与阿托西班相比,硝苯地平的心血管不良反应略有增加(证据水平2),但未增加治疗中断率(证据水平2)。鉴于阿托西班和硝苯地平在延长妊娠和良好母体耐受性方面的益处,可用于未合并PPROM的自发性早产的宫缩抑制(B级),适用于单胎和多胎妊娠(专业共识)。有利的是,硝苯地平口服给药且价格低廉(专业共识)。尼卡地平不应用于宫缩抑制(专业共识),β-拟交感神经药不应再用于宫缩抑制(C级)。所有宫缩抑制治疗的处方时间应最长为48小时(B级)。如果初始宫缩抑制失败,可建议使用另一类宫缩抑制剂进行另一种治疗(专业共识)。不同类别的宫缩抑制剂不应联合使用(C级)。缺乏科学数据来提出关于在先前首次成功进行宫缩抑制并完成产前糖皮质激素治疗后的挽救性宫缩抑制的指南(专业共识)。没有科学证据支持对宫颈扩张进展的女性进行宫缩抑制(C级),也不建议在34周后进行宫缩抑制(专业共识)。没有证据确定宫缩抑制的孕周下限(专业共识)。
硝苯地平和阿托西班可用于宫缩抑制(B级),包括多胎妊娠(专业共识)。维持宫缩抑制无用(C级)且可能有害(C级)。β-拟交感神经药不应用于宫缩抑制(专业共识)。