Sharma Anjana E, Grumbach Kevin
Center for Excellence in Primary Care, Department of Family and Community Medicine, University of California, San Francisco, CA, USA and.
San Francisco Bay Collaborative Research Network, Community Engagement and Health Policy Program, Clinical and Translational Science Institute, University of California, San Francisco, CA, USA.
Fam Pract. 2017 Jun 1;34(3):262-267. doi: 10.1093/fampra/cmw128.
Patient engagement is a fundamental strategy for achieving patient centred care and is receiving increasing attention in primary care reform efforts such as the patient-centred medical home and related care models. Much of the prior published theory and evidence supporting patient engagement has focused on improving engagement in individual care. Much less is understood about engaging patients as partners in practice improvement at the primary care clinic or practice level. We review the historical and policy context for the growing interest in the USA and UK in patient engagement at the primary care practice level, highlight findings from systematic reviews of the research evidence on practice-level patient engagement and discuss practical considerations for implementing patient engagement. We conclude that while there are persuasive ethical and social justice reasons for empowering patient involvement in practice improvement at the clinic level, research conducted to date in primary care provides suggestive but not yet resounding evidence in support of the instrumental triple aim benefit of practice-level patient engagement. We propose a research agenda to better understand the process and outcomes of practice-level patient engagement and its potential advantages to both the practice and the patients and communities served. Better evidence as well as resources to support and incentivize effective and feasible engagement methods are needed to catalyse greater diffusion of practice-level patient engagement in primary care practices.
患者参与是实现以患者为中心的医疗服务的一项基本策略,并且在诸如以患者为中心的医疗之家及相关护理模式等初级保健改革举措中受到越来越多的关注。先前发表的支持患者参与的理论和证据大多集中在提高个体护理中的参与度。而对于让患者作为初级保健诊所或医疗机构层面实践改进的合作伙伴参与其中,我们了解得则少得多。我们回顾了美国和英国对初级保健实践层面患者参与兴趣日增的历史和政策背景,强调了对实践层面患者参与研究证据的系统评价结果,并讨论了实施患者参与的实际考量因素。我们得出结论,虽然有令人信服的伦理和社会正义理由赋予患者参与诊所层面实践改进的权力,但迄今为止在初级保健领域开展的研究提供了一些暗示性而非有力的证据,以支持实践层面患者参与所带来的工具性三重目标效益。我们提出了一项研究议程,以更好地理解实践层面患者参与的过程和结果及其对医疗机构以及所服务的患者和社区的潜在优势。需要更好的证据以及资源来支持和激励有效且可行的参与方法,以促进实践层面患者参与在初级保健机构中的更广泛传播。