Somov P, Chan B K Y, Wilde C, Corbett H
Alder Hey Children's NHS Foundation Trust, Department of Paediatric Surgery, E Prescot Rd, Liverpool, L14 5AB, UK.
Alder Hey Children's NHS Foundation Trust, Department of Paediatric Surgery, E Prescot Rd, Liverpool, L14 5AB, UK.
J Pediatr Urol. 2017 Apr;13(2):208.e1-208.e4. doi: 10.1016/j.jpurol.2016.10.023. Epub 2016 Dec 9.
Over 27,000 circumcisions were performed in England in 2012-13. The complication rate is generally perceived to be low, although published figures vary widely. Balanitis xerotica obliterans, more correctly termed Lichen Sclerosus et atrophicus (LS), is one of the commonest indications for medical circumcision. To test the hypothesis that children undergoing circumcision for LS have a higher rate of postoperative bleeding than those undergoing the procedure for other reasons, we retrospectively reviewed records for patients undergoing circumcision.
The disease and procedure coding system was used to identify patients who underwent circumcision (ICD10 code N303) between 2000-2010. Cases with a diagnosis unrelated to circumcision and children circumcised during hypospadias repair were excluded. Bleeding which required return to theatre for surgical arrest was considered significant. Cases were identified by review of medical records if there was: a second procedure during the same admission, or readmission coded for circumcision within 2 weeks. Only cases with histologically confirmed LS were included in the LS cohort. GraphPad online calculator was used for statistical analysis (two tailed Fisher's exact test.
2385 boys with a median age of 4 years (range 0-16) were included in the study. Indication for circumcision included religious (1305, 54.7%), phimosis or redundant prepuce (512, 21.5%), suspected LS (366, 15.4%) and balanoposthitis (202, 8.5%). LS was histologically confirmed in 262 (10.9%) boys. Fourteen (0.6%) patients returned to theatre for surgical arrest of bleeding following circumcision; 6 had LS and 8 did not (Table 1). The bleeding rate was higher in those with LS (2.3%) than in those without (0.3%), P = 0.0003 with a relative risk of 6.08.
Post-operative complications are distressing, especially if further surgery is required. Published figures for complications following circumcision vary widely making counseling regarding risk difficult. Since LS includes an inflammatory element and circumcision in widespread LS can be challenging, the observation of more post-operative bleeding in patients with histologically confirmed LS during a previous audit prompted the hypothesis that this may be a significant finding. Thus we reviewed all patients requiring return to theatre within 2 weeks of circumcision, finding that whilst the overall bleeding rate was low, circumcision for LS significantly increased the risk. Although factors such as the severity of LS and surgical technique were not assessed, this is still a notable finding which should be reflected during pre-operative counseling.
2012 - 2013年期间,英国进行了超过27000例包皮环切术。尽管公布的数据差异很大,但一般认为并发症发生率较低。闭塞性干燥性龟头炎,更准确地称为硬化性苔藓萎缩性苔藓(LS),是医学包皮环切术最常见的指征之一。为了验证因LS接受包皮环切术的儿童术后出血率高于因其他原因接受该手术的儿童这一假设,我们回顾性地查阅了接受包皮环切术患者的记录。
使用疾病和手术编码系统识别2000 - 2010年间接受包皮环切术(ICD10编码N303)的患者。排除诊断与包皮环切术无关的病例以及在尿道下裂修复期间接受包皮环切术的儿童。需要返回手术室进行手术止血的出血被视为严重出血。如果存在以下情况,则通过查阅病历识别病例:在同一住院期间进行的第二次手术,或在2周内再次入院进行包皮环切术编码。仅将组织学确诊为LS的病例纳入LS队列。使用GraphPad在线计算器进行统计分析(双侧Fisher精确检验)。
2385名男孩纳入研究,中位年龄为4岁(范围0 - 16岁)。包皮环切术的指征包括宗教原因(1305例,54.7%)、包茎或包皮过长(512例,21.5%)、疑似LS(366例,15.4%)和龟头炎(202例,8.5%)。262名(10.9%)男孩经组织学确诊为LS。14名(0.6%)患者在包皮环切术后返回手术室进行手术止血;6名患有LS,8名未患LS(表1)。LS患者的出血率(2.3%)高于非LS患者(0.3%),P = 0.0003,相对风险为6.08。
术后并发症令人痛苦,尤其是如果需要进一步手术。包皮环切术后并发症的公布数据差异很大,这使得关于风险的咨询变得困难。由于LS包括炎症成分,并且广泛LS的包皮环切术可能具有挑战性,之前的一项审计中观察到组织学确诊为LS的患者术后出血较多,这促使我们提出这可能是一个重要发现的假设。因此,我们回顾了所有在包皮环切术后2周内需要返回手术室的患者,发现虽然总体出血率较低,但因LS进行包皮环切术显著增加了风险。尽管未评估LS的严重程度和手术技术等因素,但这仍然是一个值得注意的发现,应在术前咨询中予以体现。