González García Jonathan, Gutiérrez Nicolás Fernando, Nazco Casariego Gloria Julia, Valcárcel Nazco Cristina, Batista López Jose Norberto, Oramas Rodríguez Juana
Pharmacy Unit, Complejo Hospitalario Universitario de Canarias..
Evaluation Department, Canarian Health Service..
Farm Hosp. 2017 Jan 1;41(n01):3-13. doi: 10.7399/fh.2017.41.1.10142.
Lung cancer is the third most frequent neoplastic tumour in Spain, with around 27 000 new cases diagnosed per year; 80-95% of these are non-small-cell cancer (NSCLC), and the majority of cases are diagnosed in advanced stages of the disease, and for this reason it is one of the oncologic conditions with higher mortality rates (21.4% mean survival at 5 years). The main treatment regimens used for first-line treatment of NSCLC are: cisplatin/pemetrexed (cis/pem), cisplatin/gemcitabine/ bevacizumab (cis/gem/bev), and carboplatin/paclitaxel/ bevacizumab (carb/pac/bev). The objective of this study was to evaluate the cost-effectiveness ratio of antineoplastic 1st line NSCLC treatment regimens, from the point of view of hospital management.
A cost-efficacy mathematical model was prepared, based on a decision tree. The efficacy variable was Progression Free Survival, obtained from the PARAMOUNT, AVAIL and SAIL Phase III clinical trials. The study was conducted from the perspective of the hospital management, considering only the direct costs of drug acquisition. A deterministic sensitivity analysis was conducted to confirm the robustness of outcomes.
The PFS obtained in clinical trials with cis/pem, cis/ gem/bev and carb/pac/bev was: 6.9, 6.7 and 6.2 months, respectively. Based on our model, the mean cost of treatment per patient for these regimens was: 19 942 €, 15 594 € and 36 095 €, respectively. The incremental cost-effectiveness ratio per month of additional PFS between cis/pem and cis/gem/bev was 19 303 €. Estimating a 30% reduction in acquisition costs for pemetrexed (Alimta®Eli Lilly Nederland B.V.), due to the forthcoming launch of generic medications, the cis/pem treatment would become the predominant alternative for 1st line treatment of NSCLC patients, by offering the best health results at a lower cost.
肺癌是西班牙第三大常见肿瘤,每年约有27000例新发病例;其中80 - 95%为非小细胞癌(NSCLC),且大多数病例在疾病晚期被诊断出来,因此它是死亡率较高的肿瘤疾病之一(5年平均生存率为21.4%)。用于NSCLC一线治疗的主要治疗方案有:顺铂/培美曲塞(顺铂/培美)、顺铂/吉西他滨/贝伐单抗(顺铂/吉西/贝伐)以及卡铂/紫杉醇/贝伐单抗(卡铂/紫杉醇/贝伐)。本研究的目的是从医院管理角度评估NSCLC一线抗肿瘤治疗方案的成本效益比。
基于决策树建立了成本效益数学模型。疗效变量为无进展生存期,数据来自PARAMOUNT、AVAIL和SAIL三期临床试验。该研究从医院管理角度进行,仅考虑药品采购的直接成本。进行了确定性敏感性分析以确认结果的稳健性。
顺铂/培美、顺铂/吉西/贝伐和卡铂/紫杉醇/贝伐在临床试验中获得的无进展生存期分别为:6.9个月、6.7个月和6.2个月。根据我们的模型,这些方案每位患者的平均治疗成本分别为:19942欧元、15594欧元和36095欧元。顺铂/培美和顺铂/吉西/贝伐之间每月额外无进展生存期的增量成本效益比为19303欧元。由于即将推出培美曲塞(力比泰®,礼来荷兰有限公司)的仿制药,预计采购成本降低30%,顺铂/培美治疗将成为NSCLC患者一线治疗的主要选择,因其能以更低成本提供最佳健康效果。