Hunter J G, Becker J M, Lee R G, Christian P E, Dixon J A
Department of Surgery, University of Utah, School of Medicine, Salt Lake City.
Br J Surg. 1989 Sep;76(9):949-52. doi: 10.1002/bjs.1800760925.
Anterior lesser curvature seromyotomy combined with posterior truncal vagotomy has been suggested as an alternative to proximal gastric vagotomy in the treatment of peptic ulcer. The argon laser may be an ideal instrument for performing seromyotomy. This study compares anterior lesser curvature argon laser seromyotomy/posterior or truncal vagotomy with anterior proximal gastric vagotomy/posterior truncal vagotomy in a canine preparation. Six dogs underwent anterior lesser curvature argon laser seromyotomy/posterior truncal vagotomy and six others underwent anterior proximal gastric vagotomy/posterior truncal vagotomy. Gastric emptying and acid secretion studies were performed preoperatively and at 1 and 6 months postoperatively. Operating time and blood loss were determined. Anterior lesser curvature argon laser seromyotomy was performed with the argon laser at 10 W, continuous, delivered through a 600 micron unsheathed quartz fibre. Anterior proximal gastric vagotomy and posterior truncal vagotomy were performed in the standard fashion. Solid phase gastric emptying was slowed with both operations (P less than 0.05) but this was not manifest clinically. Blood loss (millilitres) was less following anterior lesser curvature argon laser seromyotomy/posterior truncal vagotomy than following anterior proximal gastric vagotomy/posterior truncal vagotomy (21(6.8) versus 95(28.1), mean (s.e.m.), P less than 0.05) but operating time was not significantly different between the groups. Mean basal acid secretion was reduced by 64 per cent 6 months after anterior lesser, curvature argon laser seromyotomy/posterior truncal vagotomy (P less than 0.05) and by 53 per cent after anterior proximal gastric vagotomy/posterior truncal vagotomy (not significant). Mean stimulated acid secretion was reduced by 41 per cent 6 months after anterior lesser curvature argon laser seromyotomy/posterior truncal vagotomy (P less than 0.05) and by 24 per cent after anterior proximal gastric vagotomy/posterior truncal vagotomy (not significant). We conclude that anterior lesser curvature argon laser seromyotomy/posterior truncal vagotomy is an acceptable alternative to anterior proximal gastric vagotomy/posterior truncal vagotomy and may provide superior parietal cell denervation with less operative blood loss.
有人提出,前小弯浆膜肌切开术联合后干迷走神经切断术可作为近端胃迷走神经切断术治疗消化性溃疡的替代方法。氩激光可能是进行浆膜肌切开术的理想器械。本研究在犬实验中比较了前小弯氩激光浆膜肌切开术/后干或迷走神经切断术与前近端胃迷走神经切断术/后干迷走神经切断术的效果。6只犬接受了前小弯氩激光浆膜肌切开术/后干迷走神经切断术,另外6只犬接受了前近端胃迷走神经切断术/后干迷走神经切断术。术前以及术后1个月和6个月进行了胃排空和胃酸分泌研究。测定了手术时间和失血量。前小弯氩激光浆膜肌切开术使用氩激光,功率10W,连续输出,通过一根600微米无鞘石英纤维传输。前近端胃迷走神经切断术和后干迷走神经切断术按标准方式进行。两种手术均使固相胃排空减慢(P<0.05),但临床上未表现出来。前小弯氩激光浆膜肌切开术/后干迷走神经切断术后的失血量(毫升)少于前近端胃迷走神经切断术/后干迷走神经切断术(分别为21(6.8) 与95(28.1),均值(标准误),P<0.05),但两组间手术时间无显著差异。前小弯氩激光浆膜肌切开术/后干迷走神经切断术后6个月,基础胃酸分泌平均减少64%(P<0.05),前近端胃迷走神经切断术/后干迷走神经切断术后减少53%(无显著差异)。前小弯氩激光浆膜肌切开术/后干迷走神经切断术后6个月,刺激胃酸分泌平均减少41%(P<0.05),前近端胃迷走神经切断术/后干迷走神经切断术后减少24%(无显著差异)。我们得出结论,前小弯氩激光浆膜肌切开术/后干迷走神经切断术是前近端胃迷走神经切断术/后干迷走神经切断术可接受的替代方法,可能在减少手术失血量的情况下提供更好的壁细胞去神经支配效果。