Neutel C I
Can J Public Health. 1989 Sep-Oct;80(5):375-9.
All commercial fishermen in the Canadian Maritime provinces (Nova Scotia, New Brunswick, and Prince Edward Island) are registered with the Department of Fisheries and Oceans (DFO). The data obtained by DFO during 1975-1983 on 33,000 fishermen were linked with the Canadian Mortality Data Base by the record linkage procedures in place at Statistics Canada, thus identifying 1,289 male deaths. When Canadian mortality rates were used to calculate the expected number of deaths, the standardized mortality ratio (SMR) was 0.80 for all causes. The rather low SMR can be explained at least partially by "the healthy worker effect". Although the healthy worker effect is generally greater for the younger age groups (i.e. a lower SMR), in this study the all-causes SMR for those under 44 years of age was 1.5. All accidents together showed an SMR of 1.5 which was even higher for the younger age groups (1.75). The most striking finding was the ratio for water transport accidents where observed deaths occurred at 8.5 times the expected rate. SMR for cancers were somewhat high, especially cancer of the pancreas at 1.5. Notable also were the very low rates for respiratory diseases although the younger fishermen still had an SMR greater than one. From a public health point of view, the high accident mortality for all fishermen and high mortality for many causes at the most productive ages associated with this occupation is of concern.
加拿大海洋省份(新斯科舍省、新不伦瑞克省和爱德华王子岛)的所有商业渔民都在渔业和海洋部(DFO)进行了注册。DFO在1975年至1983年期间获取的33000名渔民的数据,通过加拿大统计局现有的记录链接程序与加拿大死亡率数据库相链接,从而确定了1289例男性死亡病例。当使用加拿大死亡率来计算预期死亡人数时,所有原因的标准化死亡率(SMR)为0.80。相当低的SMR至少可以部分地用“健康工人效应”来解释。虽然健康工人效应在较年轻年龄组中通常更大(即SMR较低),但在本研究中,44岁以下人群的全因SMR为1.5。所有事故的SMR为1.5,在较年轻年龄组中甚至更高(1.75)。最引人注目的发现是水上运输事故的比率,观察到的死亡发生率是预期发生率的8.5倍。癌症的SMR有些高,尤其是胰腺癌为1.5。呼吸道疾病的发生率也非常低,不过较年轻的渔民的SMR仍大于1。从公共卫生的角度来看,所有渔民的高事故死亡率以及与该职业相关的最具生产力年龄段的多种原因导致的高死亡率令人担忧。