Harris Michael A, Beenken Karen E, Smeltzer Mark S, Haggard Warren O, Jennings J Amber
The University of Memphis, Department of Biomedical Engineering, 330 Engineering Technology, 3796 Norriswood Avenue, Memphis, TN, 38152, USA.
Department of Microbiology & Immunology and Department of Orthopaedics, The University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences, Little Rock, AR, USA.
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2017 Jul;475(7):1847-1853. doi: 10.1007/s11999-016-5211-7.
Phosphatidylcholine coatings have been shown to elute antibiotics for several days. A recently developed biofilm inhibitor, cis-2-decenoic acid (C2DA), has been shown to exhibit synergistic activity with several common antibiotics. This study aims to evaluate the effectiveness of C2DA and amikacin dual drug delivery from a phosphatidylcholine coating.
QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: (1) What are the in vitro elution profiles of amikacin and C2DA from phosphatidylcholine-coated coupons in incubated phosphate-buffered saline? (2) Does the presence of C2DA in eluate samples lower the amount of amikacin needed for bacterial inhibition in overnight bacterial turbidity assays? (3) Does addition of amikacin and C2DA result in decreased colony-forming units (CFUs) on wire implants and bone when compared with phosphatidylcholine coatings alone in a mouse model of periprosthetic joint infection?
Effects of loading concentrations were assessed during 7-day in vitro elution studies for coatings containing all mixtures of 0%, 5%, 15%, and 25% wt of amikacin and C2DA (n = 4) through quantitative high-performance liquid chromatography concentration determination and plotting concentration eluted over time. Antimicrobial activity was assessed by overnight turbidity testing of elution study samples against Staphylococcus aureus or Pseudomonas aeruginosa. In vivo efficacy was assessed using phosphatidylcholine-coated wire implants in a murine (mouse) model of infection (n = 3). Wire implants were coated with phosphatidylcholine containing no antimicrobials, amikacin alone, C2DA alone, or amikacin and C2DA and then inserted into the intramedullary femur of each mouse and inoculated with S aureus. The number of viable bacterial colonies on the implant surface and in the surrounding bone was determined after 1 week with the goal of achieving complete bacterial clearance. Total viable CFU count and proportion of samples achieving complete clearance were compared between groups.
Elution samples showed a burst response of amikacin and C2DA for 1 to 2 days with C2DA release continuing at low levels through Day 4. All tested eluate samples inhibited P aeruginosa. Samples from coatings containing 25% amikacin or 15% amikacin and any amount of C2DA were able to inhibit S aureus formation, but all coatings with 5% amikacin or 15% amikacin but no C2DA were not inhibitory. All in vivo treatment groups achieved complete bacterial clearance on the wire implant, and the C2DA alone and amikacin alone coatings cleared all CFUs in bone (pin: phosphatidylcholine only one of three; amikacin three of three, C2DA three of three, amikacin + C2DA three of three, p = 0.04 [Fisher's exact test]; bone: coating only: zero of three; amikacin: three of three; C2DA; three of three; C2DA + amikacin: one of three; p = 0.03 [Fisher's exact test]).
Phosphatidylcholine coatings elute antimicrobials in vitro under infinite sink conditions for up to 4 days in phosphate-buffered saline and were able to reduce bacterial colonies in a preliminary in vivo model. Turbidity testing with eluate samples containing varying amounts of C2DA and amikacin agrees with previous studies showing synergy between them.
Used as an adjunctive to systemic therapy, C2DA-loaded phosphatidylcholine coatings have potential value as a prophylactic infection prevention measure. Future studies may include different antibiotics, animal studies with larger sample sizes and more controls, and advanced coating delivery methods.
已表明磷脂酰胆碱涂层可洗脱抗生素达数天之久。最近开发的一种生物膜抑制剂顺式-2-癸烯酸(C2DA),已显示出与几种常见抗生素具有协同活性。本研究旨在评估从磷脂酰胆碱涂层中双重递送C2DA和阿米卡星的有效性。
问题/目的:(1)在孵育的磷酸盐缓冲盐水中,阿米卡星和C2DA从磷脂酰胆碱包被的试片中的体外洗脱曲线是怎样的?(2)洗脱液样品中C2DA的存在是否会降低过夜细菌浊度测定中抑制细菌所需的阿米卡星量?(3)在假体周围关节感染的小鼠模型中,与单独的磷脂酰胆碱涂层相比,添加阿米卡星和C2DA是否会导致钢丝植入物和骨上的菌落形成单位(CFU)减少?
在为期7天的体外洗脱研究中,通过定量高效液相色谱浓度测定并绘制随时间洗脱的浓度曲线,评估了含0%、5%、15%和25%重量比的阿米卡星和C2DA所有混合物的涂层(n = 4)的负载浓度的影响。通过对洗脱研究样品针对金黄色葡萄球菌或铜绿假单胞菌进行过夜浊度测试来评估抗菌活性。使用磷脂酰胆碱包被的钢丝植入物在小鼠感染模型(n = 3)中评估体内疗效。钢丝植入物涂覆不含抗菌剂的磷脂酰胆碱、单独的阿米卡星、单独的C2DA或阿米卡星和C2DA,然后插入每只小鼠的股骨髓腔内并接种金黄色葡萄球菌。1周后测定植入物表面和周围骨中活细菌菌落的数量,目标是实现细菌的完全清除。比较各组之间的总活CFU计数和实现完全清除的样品比例。
洗脱样品显示阿米卡星和C2DA在1至2天内有一个突发反应,C2DA释放持续到第4天仍处于低水平。所有测试的洗脱液样品均能抑制铜绿假单胞菌。含25%阿米卡星或15%阿米卡星与任何量C2DA的涂层样品能够抑制金黄色葡萄球菌形成,但所有含5%阿米卡星或15%阿米卡星但不含C2DA的涂层均无抑制作用。所有体内治疗组在钢丝植入物上均实现了细菌的完全清除,单独的C2DA和单独的阿米卡星涂层清除了骨中的所有CFU(针:仅磷脂酰胆碱组三只中有一只;阿米卡星组三只中有三只;C2DA组三只中有三只;阿米卡星+C2DA组三只中有三只,p = 0.04[Fisher精确检验];骨:仅涂层组三只中有零只;阿米卡星组三只中有三只;C2DA组三只中有三只;C2DA+阿米卡星组三只中有一只;p = 0.03[Fisher精确检验])。
在无限下沉条件下,磷脂酰胆碱涂层在磷酸盐缓冲盐水中体外洗脱抗菌剂可达4天,并能够在初步的体内模型中减少细菌菌落。对含不同量C2DA和阿米卡星的洗脱液样品进行的浊度测试与先前显示它们之间协同作用的研究结果一致。
作为全身治疗的辅助手段,负载C2DA的磷脂酰胆碱涂层作为预防性感染预防措施具有潜在价值。未来的研究可能包括不同的抗生素、更大样本量和更多对照的动物研究以及先进的涂层递送方法。