Cook Elizabeth Anne Jessie, de Glanville William Anson, Thomas Lian Francesca, Kariuki Samuel, Bronsvoort Barend Mark de Clare, Fèvre Eric Maurice
Centre for Immunity, Infection and Evolution, Institute for Immunology and Infection Research, School of Biological Sciences, University of Edinburgh, Ashworth Laboratories, West Mains Road, Edinburgh, EH9 3JT, UK.
International Livestock Research Institute, Old Naivasha Road, PO Box 30709, 00100, Nairobi, Kenya.
BMC Public Health. 2017 Jan 5;17(1):14. doi: 10.1186/s12889-016-3923-y.
Inadequate facilities and hygiene at slaughterhouses can result in contamination of meat and occupational hazards to workers. The objectives of this study were to assess current conditions in slaughterhouses in western Kenya and the knowledge, and practices of the slaughterhouse workers toward hygiene and sanitation.
Between February and October 2012 all consenting slaughterhouses in the study area were recruited. A standardised questionnaire relating to facilities and practices in the slaughterhouse was administered to the foreperson at each site. A second questionnaire was used to capture individual slaughterhouse workers' knowledge, practices and recent health events.
A total of 738 slaughterhouse workers from 142 slaughterhouses completed questionnaires. Many slaughterhouses had poor infrastructure, 65% (95% CI 63-67%) had a roof, cement floor and walls, 60% (95% CI 57-62%) had a toilet and 20% (95% CI 18-22%) had hand-washing facilities. The meat inspector visited 90% (95% CI 92-95%) of slaughterhouses but antemortem inspection was practiced at only 7% (95% CI 6-8%). Nine percent (95% CI 7-10%) of slaughterhouses slaughtered sick animals. Only half of workers wore personal protective clothing - 53% (95% CI 51-55%) wore protective coats and 49% (95% CI 46-51%) wore rubber boots. Knowledge of zoonotic disease was low with only 31% (95% CI 29-33%) of workers aware that disease could be transmitted from animals.
The current working conditions in slaughterhouses in western Kenya are not in line with the recommendations of the Meat Control Act of Kenya. Current facilities and practices may increase occupational exposure to disease or injury and contaminated meat may enter the consumer market. The findings of this study could enable the development of appropriate interventions to minimise public health risks. Initially, improvements need to be made to facilities and practices to improve worker safety and reduce the risk of food contamination. Simultaneously, training programmes should target workers and inspectors to improve awareness of the risks. In addition, education of health care workers should highlight the increased risks of injury and disease in slaughterhouse workers. Finally, enhanced surveillance, targeting slaughterhouse workers could be used to detect disease outbreaks. This "One Health" approach to disease surveillance is likely to benefit workers, producers and consumers.
屠宰场设施不足和卫生条件差会导致肉类污染,并给工人带来职业危害。本研究的目的是评估肯尼亚西部屠宰场的现状,以及屠宰场工人对卫生和环境卫生的知识与做法。
2012年2月至10月期间,招募了研究区域内所有同意参与的屠宰场。向每个屠宰场的工头发放了一份关于屠宰场设施和做法的标准化问卷。另一份问卷用于获取个体屠宰场工人的知识、做法和近期健康事件。
来自142个屠宰场的738名屠宰场工人完成了问卷。许多屠宰场基础设施较差,65%(95%置信区间63 - 67%)有屋顶、水泥地面和墙壁,60%(95%置信区间57 - 62%)有厕所,20%(95%置信区间18 - 22%)有洗手设施。肉类检查员走访了90%(95%置信区间92 - 95%)的屠宰场,但仅7%(95%置信区间6 - 8%)的屠宰场进行宰前检查。9%(95%置信区间7 - 10%)的屠宰场宰杀生病的动物。只有一半的工人穿个人防护服——53%(95%置信区间51 - 55%)穿防护外套,49%(95%置信区间46 - 51%)穿橡胶靴。对人畜共患病的知晓率较低,只有31%(95%置信区间29 - 33%)的工人意识到疾病可从动物传播。
肯尼亚西部屠宰场目前的工作条件不符合肯尼亚《肉类控制法》的建议。当前的设施和做法可能会增加职业接触疾病或受伤的风险,受污染的肉类可能会进入消费市场。本研究的结果有助于制定适当的干预措施,以尽量减少公共卫生风险。首先,需要改善设施和做法,以提高工人安全并降低食品污染风险。同时,培训计划应针对工人和检查员,以提高对风险的认识。此外,对医护人员的教育应强调屠宰场工人受伤和患病风险的增加。最后,针对屠宰场工人加强监测可用于发现疾病暴发。这种“同一健康”的疾病监测方法可能会使工人、生产者和消费者受益。