Faglioni P, Scarpa M
Neurological Department, Modena University.
Cortex. 1989 Sep;25(3):449-59. doi: 10.1016/s0010-9452(89)80058-9.
This study aimed at assessing whether there was a relation between presence or absence of apraxia following a parietal and/or frontal left hemisphere lesion and "typical" skull asymmetries, evidenced by CT scan (prevalence of the left over the right occipital length and width and of the right over the left frontal length and width). Skull asymmetries were measured in a sample of 160 brain-damaged patients and their prevalence was found to agree with those reported by the literature in normal subjects. A subgroup of 72 patients with lesions restricted to the parietal and/or frontal lobe were given a movement imitation test and diagnosed as apraxic, borderline or normal making reference to the performance of 150 control subjects. The incidence in these three groups of typical or atypical occipital and frontal asymmetries was assessed and found not to differ significantly. It is concluded that no consistent relation between hemisphere dominance for praxis and skull asymmetry can be asserted. The study also investigated the relation of idemotor apraxia to the locus of left hemisphere damage and confirmed that both the incidence and the severity of the disorder are much greater following parietal than frontal lesions.
本研究旨在评估左半球顶叶和/或额叶病变后失用症的有无与“典型”颅骨不对称之间是否存在关联,这种颅骨不对称通过CT扫描得以证实(左枕骨长度和宽度大于右枕骨,以及右额叶长度和宽度大于左额叶的发生率)。在160名脑损伤患者的样本中测量了颅骨不对称情况,发现其发生率与文献报道的正常受试者情况相符。对72名病变局限于顶叶和/或额叶的患者亚组进行了运动模仿测试,并参照150名对照受试者的表现将其诊断为失用症、临界或正常。评估了这三组中典型或非典型枕叶和额叶不对称的发生率,发现无显著差异。得出的结论是,不能断言运动优势半球与颅骨不对称之间存在一致的关系。该研究还调查了观念运动性失用症与左半球损伤部位的关系,并证实该障碍的发生率和严重程度在顶叶病变后比额叶病变后要高得多。