Smart M D, Cornman R S, Iwanowicz D D, McDermott-Kubeczko M, Pettis J S, Spivak M S, Otto C R V
U.S. Geological Survey Northern Prairie Wildlife Research Center, Jamestown, ND (
U.S. Geological Survey Fort Collins Science Center, Fort Collins, CO (
Environ Entomol. 2017 Feb 1;46(1):38-49. doi: 10.1093/ee/nvw159.
Taxonomic identification of pollen has historically been accomplished via light microscopy but requires specialized knowledge and reference collections, particularly when identification to lower taxonomic levels is necessary. Recently, next-generation sequencing technology has been used as a cost-effective alternative for identifying bee-collected pollen; however, this novel approach has not been tested on a spatially or temporally robust number of pollen samples. Here, we compare pollen identification results derived from light microscopy and DNA sequencing techniques with samples collected from honey bee colonies embedded within a gradient of intensive agricultural landscapes in the Northern Great Plains throughout the 2010-2011 growing seasons. We demonstrate that at all taxonomic levels, DNA sequencing was able to discern a greater number of taxa, and was particularly useful for the identification of infrequently detected species. Importantly, substantial phenological overlap did occur for commonly detected taxa using either technique, suggesting that DNA sequencing is an appropriate, and enhancing, substitutive technique for accurately capturing the breadth of bee-collected species of pollen present across agricultural landscapes. We also show that honey bees located in high and low intensity agricultural settings forage on dissimilar plants, though with overlap of the most abundantly collected pollen taxa. We highlight practical applications of utilizing sequencing technology, including addressing ecological issues surrounding land use, climate change, importance of taxa relative to abundance, and evaluating the impact of conservation program habitat enhancement efforts.
从历史上看,花粉的分类鉴定是通过光学显微镜完成的,但这需要专业知识和参考标本集,尤其是在需要鉴定到较低分类水平时。最近,新一代测序技术已被用作鉴定蜜蜂采集花粉的一种经济高效的替代方法;然而,这种新方法尚未在空间或时间上数量足够多的花粉样本上进行测试。在这里,我们将光学显微镜和DNA测序技术得出的花粉鉴定结果与2010 - 2011年生长季节从大平原北部集约化农业景观梯度中嵌入的蜜蜂蜂群采集的样本进行比较。我们证明,在所有分类水平上,DNA测序能够识别出更多的分类群,并且对于鉴定不常检测到的物种特别有用。重要的是,使用这两种技术对常见检测到的分类群确实存在大量物候重叠,这表明DNA测序是一种合适的、能够增强的替代技术,可用于准确捕捉农业景观中蜜蜂采集的花粉物种的广度。我们还表明,位于高强度和低强度农业环境中的蜜蜂采集不同的植物,但最丰富采集的花粉分类群存在重叠。我们强调了利用测序技术的实际应用,包括解决围绕土地利用、气候变化、分类群相对于丰度的重要性以及评估保护计划栖息地改善努力的影响等生态问题。