Wang Yu, Ma Meng-Yun, Jiang Xin-Yu, Wang Jiang-Feng, Li Liang-Liang, Yin Xiao-Jun, Wang Min, Lai Yue, Tao Lu-Yang
Department of Forensic Medicine, Soochow University, Ganjiang East Road, Suzhou 215000, China; Department of Entomology, College of Agriculture, South China Agricultural University, Wushan Road, Guangzhou 510642, China.
Criminal Police Branch, Shenzhen Public Security Bureau, Jiefang Road, Shenzhen 518000, China.
Forensic Sci Int. 2017 Feb;271:75-86. doi: 10.1016/j.forsciint.2016.12.032. Epub 2016 Dec 28.
Most forensic entomological succession studies have been carried out using pig or rabbit carcasses; however, there have been few studies on the differences between insect succession patterns on human cadavers and on animal carcasses. In order to clarify the differences between decomposition and insect succession patterns of human cadavers and animal carcasses, one 49.5kg human cadaver, two large pig carcasses (45 and 48kg), two small pig carcasses (23 and 25kg) and two rabbit carcasses (both 1.75kg) were placed in the same field conditions in Shenzhen, China for a comparative study on August, 2013. The results indicated that: (1) The duration from fresh to skeletonization is in order of human cadaver>large pig carcasses>small pig carcasses>rabbit carcasses; (2) insect assemblages (including developmental stages) are more complex on larger carcasses, in order of human cadaver=large pig carcasses>small pig carcasses>rabbit carcasses; (3) the developmental rates of the same forensically important fly species on all carcasses are consistent; (4) all identified species of Calliphoridae can complete development of one generation on human cadaver, and both large and small pig carcasses, while on rabbit carcasses, only a subset of the Calliphoridae species can finish development of one generation; (5) beetles can generate offspring on human cadaver, and both large and small pig carcasses, while they do not generate offspring on rabbit carcasses. This study provides useful comparative data for decomposition and insect succession pattern of human cadaver with animal carcasses.
大多数法医昆虫演替研究都是使用猪或兔子的尸体进行的;然而,关于人类尸体和动物尸体上昆虫演替模式的差异的研究却很少。为了阐明人类尸体和动物尸体在分解和昆虫演替模式上的差异,2013年8月,在中国深圳的相同野外条件下放置了一具49.5千克的人类尸体、两具大猪尸体(45千克和48千克)、两具小猪尸体(23千克和25千克)以及两具兔子尸体(均为1.75千克),以进行比较研究。结果表明:(1)从新鲜到白骨化的持续时间顺序为人类尸体>大猪尸体>小猪尸体>兔子尸体;(2)较大尸体上的昆虫群落(包括发育阶段)更为复杂,顺序为人类尸体=大猪尸体>小猪尸体>兔子尸体;(3)所有尸体上相同的具有法医重要性的蝇类物种的发育速度是一致的;(4)所有已鉴定的丽蝇科物种都能在人类尸体、大猪尸体和小猪尸体上完成一代发育,而在兔子尸体上,只有一部分丽蝇科物种能完成一代发育;(5)甲虫能在人类尸体、大猪尸体和小猪尸体上繁殖后代,而在兔子尸体上则不能繁殖后代。本研究为人类尸体与动物尸体的分解和昆虫演替模式提供了有用的比较数据。