van den Heuvel Meta, Martimianakis Maria Athina Tina, Levy Rebecca, Atkinson Adelle, Ford-Jones Elizabeth, Shouldice Michelle
Department of Paediatrics, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Division of Paediatric Medicine, Hospital for Sick Children, M5G 1X8, 555 University Avenue, Toronto, ON, Canada.
BMC Med Educ. 2017 Jan 13;17(1):12. doi: 10.1186/s12909-016-0845-4.
Social pediatrics teaches pediatric residents how to understand disease within their patients' social, environmental and political contexts. It's an essential component of pediatric residency training; however there is very little literature that addresses how such a broad-ranging topic can be taught effectively. The aim of this study was to determine and characterize social pediatric education in our pediatric residency training in order to identify strengths and gaps.
A social pediatrics curriculum map was developed, attending to 3 different dimensions: (1) the intended curriculum as prescribed by the Objectives of Training for Pediatrics of the Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada (RCPSC), (2) the formal curriculum defined by rotation-specific learning objectives, and (3) the informal/hidden curriculum as reflected in resident and teacher experiences and perceptions.
Forty-one social pediatric learning objectives were extracted from the RCPSC Objectives of Training for Pediatrics, most were listed in the Medical Expert (51%) and Health Advocate competencies (24%). Almost all RCPSC social pediatric learning objectives were identified in more than one rotation and/or seminar. Adolescent Medicine (29.2%), Pediatric Ambulatory Medicine (26.2%) and Developmental Pediatrics (25%) listed the highest proportion of social pediatric learning objectives. Four (10%) RCPSC social pediatric objectives were not explicitly named within learning objectives of the formal curriculum. The informal curriculum revealed that both teachers and residents viewed social pediatrics as integral to all clinical encounters. Perceived barriers to teaching and learning of social pediatrics included time constraints, particularly in a tertiary care environment, and the value of social pediatrics relative to medical expert knowledge.
Despite the lack of an explicit thematic presentation of social pediatric learning objectives by the Royal College and residency training program, social pediatric topics are integrated, taught and learned throughout the entire curriculum. Special attention needs to be given to the hidden curriculum and system barriers that may impede social pediatric education.
社会儿科学教导儿科住院医师如何在患者的社会、环境和政治背景中理解疾病。它是儿科住院医师培训的重要组成部分;然而,关于如何有效教授这一广泛主题的文献却非常少。本研究的目的是确定并描述我们儿科住院医师培训中的社会儿科学教育,以识别优势和差距。
制定了一份社会儿科学课程地图,涉及三个不同维度:(1)加拿大皇家内科医师和外科医师学院(RCPSC)儿科培训目标规定的预期课程;(2)由特定轮转学习目标定义的正式课程;(3)住院医师和教师的经验及认知所反映的非正式/隐性课程。
从RCPSC儿科培训目标中提取了41个社会儿科学学习目标,大多数列在医学专家能力(51%)和健康倡导者能力(24%)中。几乎所有RCPSC社会儿科学学习目标都在不止一个轮转和/或研讨会上被提及。青少年医学(29.2%)、儿科门诊医学(26.2%)和发育儿科学(25%)列出的社会儿科学学习目标比例最高。4个(10%)RCPSC社会儿科学目标在正式课程的学习目标中未被明确提及。隐性课程显示,教师和住院医师都认为社会儿科学是所有临床接触中不可或缺的一部分。社会儿科学教学和学习的感知障碍包括时间限制,尤其是在三级医疗环境中,以及社会儿科学相对于医学专家知识的价值。
尽管皇家学院和住院医师培训项目缺乏对社会儿科学学习目标的明确主题呈现,但社会儿科学主题在整个课程中都有整合、教授和学习。需要特别关注可能阻碍社会儿科学教育的隐性课程和系统障碍。