Hrabovsky Dušan, Balaz Marek, Bockova Martina, Feitova Věra, Novak Zdeněk, Chrastina Jan
Masaryk University, Medical Faculty, St. Anne's Hospital, Department of Neurosurgery, Brno, Czech Republic.
Turk Neurosurg. 2018;28(2):296-302. doi: 10.5137/1019-5149.JTN.19450-16.0.
Advances in neuroradiological planning techniques in deep brain stimulation have put the need for intraoperative electrophysiological monitoring into doubt. Moreover intraoperative monitoring prolongs surgical time and there is potential association between the use of microelectrodes and increased incidence of hemorrhagic complications. The aim of this study was to analyze the correlation between the anatomically planned trajectory and the final subthalamic electrode placement after electrophysiological monitoring in patients with Parkinson"s disease and its change with the increasing experience of the surgical team.
The trajectories of right (first implanted) and left electrodes were compared in the first 50 patients operated on (Group 1) and the next 50 patients (Group 2).
In Group 1, 52% of central trajectories were on the right and 38% on the left; in Group 2, the percentage of central trajectories was 76% on the right and 78% on the left; the difference was statistically significant (p=0.021 and 0.001). The difference in the percentage of posterior trajectories reflecting brain shift between the right and left sides was statistically insignificant in Groups 1 (26% and 28%, p=0.999) and 2 (18% and 12%, p=0.549). The percentage of bilateral central electrodes was 14% and 62% in Groups 1 and 2, respectively.
The correlation between anatomically planned trajectory and final electrode placement markedly improves with the number of patients. However the significant percentage of patients with final electrode trajectory differing from anatomically planned target supports the use of intraoperative monitoring.
深部脑刺激神经放射学规划技术的进展使术中电生理监测的必要性受到质疑。此外,术中监测会延长手术时间,并且使用微电极与出血并发症发生率增加之间可能存在关联。本研究的目的是分析帕金森病患者在电生理监测后解剖学规划轨迹与最终丘脑底核电极置入之间的相关性,以及随着手术团队经验的增加其变化情况。
比较了首批接受手术的50例患者(第1组)和接下来的50例患者(第2组)右侧(首次植入)和左侧电极的轨迹。
在第1组中,中央轨迹52%在右侧,38%在左侧;在第2组中,中央轨迹右侧的百分比为76%,左侧为78%;差异具有统计学意义(p = 0.021和0.001)。第1组(26%和28%,p = 0.999)和第2组(18%和12%,p = 0.549)中反映脑移位的后轨迹百分比在左右两侧的差异无统计学意义。第1组和第2组双侧中央电极的百分比分别为14%和62%。
随着患者数量的增加,解剖学规划轨迹与最终电极置入之间的相关性显著改善。然而,最终电极轨迹与解剖学规划目标不同的患者比例较高,这支持了术中监测的使用。