Milo Marva
a Gender, Feminist, and Women's Studies , York University , Toronto , Ontario , Canada.
J Homosex. 2017;64(7):889-907. doi: 10.1080/00918369.2017.1280991.
This essay examines Middle East representations in U.S. homophile periodicals from 1953 to 1964. The essay uses more than 120 Middle East-related items that were published in ONE, Mattachine Review, and The Ladder to address the periodicals' engagement with the region (particularly ancient history and biblical themes) and discuss the types of sexual "knowledge" that the homophile periodicals created about the region. It then assesses the role of periodicals as a genre in the creation of a transnational homophile community, showing both their potential for democratizing participation in this community and their limits. The essay argues that the periodicals made visible the process of assembling a homosexual identity and the fragmentary nature of the parts it strove to unify. Though the views of key U.S. homophile organizations became hegemonic in the international gay rights movement, the periodicals show a more complex, ambivalent, and contested process.
本文考察了1953年至1964年美国同性恋期刊中对中东地区的呈现。本文使用了在《一》《马特钦评论》和《阶梯》上发表的120多篇与中东相关的文章,来探讨这些期刊与该地区的关联(尤其是古代历史和圣经主题),并讨论同性恋期刊所创造的关于该地区的性“知识”类型。然后,本文评估了期刊作为一种体裁在创建跨国同性恋社群过程中的作用,既展示了它们在使该社群参与民主化方面的潜力,也指出了其局限性。本文认为,这些期刊揭示了构建同性恋身份的过程以及它试图统一的各个部分的碎片化本质。尽管美国主要同性恋组织的观点在国际同性恋权利运动中占据了主导地位,但这些期刊展示了一个更为复杂、矛盾和有争议的过程。