Stapelfeldt Wolf H, Yuan Hui, Dryden Jefferson K, Strehl Kristen E, Cywinski Jacek B, Ehrenfeld Jesse M, Bromley Pamela
From the *Department of Anesthesiology and Critical Care Medicine, Saint Louis University School of Medicine, St. Louis, Missouri; †Department of General Anesthesiology, Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, Ohio; and ‡Department of Anesthesiology, Vanderbilt University, Nashville, Tennessee.
Anesth Analg. 2017 Apr;124(4):1135-1152. doi: 10.1213/ANE.0000000000001797.
It has been suggested that longer-term postsurgical outcome may be adversely affected by less than severe hypotension under anesthesia. However, evidence-based guidelines are unavailable. The present study was designed to develop a method for identifying patients at increased risk of death within 30 days in association with the severity and duration of intraoperative hypotension.
Intraoperative mean arterial blood pressure recordings of 152,445 adult patients undergoing noncardiac surgery were analyzed for periods of time accumulated below each one of the 31 thresholds between 75 and 45 mm Hg (hypotensive exposure times). In a development cohort of 35,904 patients, the associations were sought between each of these 31 cumulative hypotensive exposure times and 30-day postsurgical mortality. On the basis of covariable-adjusted percentage increases in the odds of mortality per minute elapsed of hypotensive exposure time, certain sets of exposure time limits were calculated that portended certain percentage increases in the odds of mortality. A novel risk-scoring method was conceived by counting the number of exposure time limits that had been exceeded within each respective set, one of them being called the SLUScore. The validity of this new method in identifying patients at increased risk was tested in a multicenter validation cohort consisting of 116,541 patients from Cleveland Clinic, Vanderbilt and Saint Louis Universities. Data were expressed as 95% confidence interval, P < .05 considered significant.
Progressively greater hypotensive exposures were associated with greater 30-day mortality. In the development cohort, covariable-adjusted (age, Charlson score, case duration, history of hypertension) exposure limits were identified for time accumulated below each of the thresholds that portended certain identical (5%-50%) percentage expected increases in the odds of mortality. These exposure time limit sets were shorter in patients with a history of hypertension. A novel risk score, the SLUScore (range 0-31), was conceived as the number of exposure limits exceeded for one of these sets (20% set). A SLUScore > 0 (average 13.8) was found in 40% of patients who had twice the mortality, adjusted odds increasing by 5% per limit exceeded. When tested in the validation cohort, a SLUScore > 0 (average 14.1) identified 35% of patients who had twice the mortality, each incremental limit exceeded portending a 5% compounding increase in adjusted odds of mortality, independent of age and Charlson score (C = 0.73, 0.72-0.74, P < .05).
The SLUScore represents a novel method for identifying nearly 1 in every 3 patients experiencing greater 30-day mortality portended by more severe intraoperative hypotensive exposures.
有人提出,麻醉期间不太严重的低血压可能会对长期术后结果产生不利影响。然而,尚无循证指南。本研究旨在开发一种方法,以识别与术中低血压的严重程度和持续时间相关的30天内死亡风险增加的患者。
分析了152445例接受非心脏手术的成年患者的术中平均动脉血压记录,统计低于75至45毫米汞柱之间31个阈值中每个阈值的累计时间(低血压暴露时间)。在35904例患者的开发队列中,研究了这31个累计低血压暴露时间中的每一个与术后30天死亡率之间的关联。根据低血压暴露时间每经过一分钟死亡率几率的协变量调整百分比增加情况,计算出预示死亡率几率有一定百分比增加的特定暴露时间限制集。通过计算每个相应集合中超过的暴露时间限制数量,构思了一种新的风险评分方法,其中一个被称为SLUScore。在由克利夫兰诊所、范德比尔特大学和圣路易斯大学的116541例患者组成的多中心验证队列中测试了这种新方法在识别风险增加患者方面的有效性。数据以95%置信区间表示,P <.05被视为具有统计学意义。
低血压暴露程度越高,30天死亡率越高。在开发队列中,确定了协变量调整(年龄、查尔森评分、病例持续时间、高血压病史)后的暴露限制,即低于每个阈值的累计时间,这些时间预示着死亡率几率有相同的(5%-50%)预期百分比增加。有高血压病史的患者这些暴露时间限制集较短。构思了一种新的风险评分,即SLUScore(范围0-31),作为这些集合之一(20%集合)中超过的暴露限制数量。在死亡率高出两倍的患者中,40%的患者SLUScore > 0(平均13.8),每超过一个限制,调整后的死亡率几率增加5%。在验证队列中进行测试时,SLUScore > 0(平均14.1)识别出死亡率高出两倍的患者中的35%,每超过一个递增限制,调整后的死亡率几率就会有5%的复合增加,与年龄和查尔森评分无关(C = 0.73,0.72-0.74,P <.05)。
SLUScore是一种新方法,可识别近三分之一因术中更严重的低血压暴露而预示30天死亡率更高的患者。