Metsomaa Johanna, Sarvas Jukka, Ilmoniemi Risto Juhani
IEEE Trans Biomed Eng. 2017 Sep;64(9):2054-2064. doi: 10.1109/TBME.2016.2616389. Epub 2016 Oct 12.
Blind source separation (BSS) can be used to decompose complex electroencephalography (EEG) or magnetoencephalography data into simpler components based on statistical assumptions without using a physical model. Applications include brain-computer interfaces, artifact removal, and identifying parallel neural processes. We wish to address the issue of applying BSS to event-related responses, which is challenging because of nonstationary data.
We introduce a new BSS approach called momentary-uncorrelated component analysis (MUCA), which is tailored for event-related multitrial data. The method is based on approximate joint diagonalization of multiple covariance matrices estimated from the data at separate latencies. We further show how to extend the methodology for autocovariance matrices and how to apply BSS methods suitable for piecewise stationary data to event-related responses. We compared several BSS approaches by using simulated EEG as well as measured somatosensory and transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS) evoked EEG.
Among the compared methods, MUCA was the most tolerant one to noise, TMS artifacts, and other challenges in the data. With measured somatosensory data, over half of the estimated components were found to be similar by MUCA and independent component analysis. MUCA was also stable when tested with several input datasets.
MUCA is based on simple assumptions, and the results suggest that MUCA is robust with nonideal data.
Event-related responses and BSS are valuable and popular tools in neuroscience. Correctly designed BSS is an efficient way of identifying artifactual and neural processes from nonstationary event-related data.
盲源分离(BSS)可用于在不使用物理模型的情况下,基于统计假设将复杂的脑电图(EEG)或脑磁图数据分解为更简单的成分。其应用包括脑机接口、伪迹去除以及识别并行神经过程。我们希望解决将BSS应用于事件相关反应的问题,由于数据的非平稳性,这具有挑战性。
我们引入了一种新的BSS方法,称为瞬时不相关成分分析(MUCA),它是为事件相关的多次试验数据量身定制的。该方法基于从不同潜伏期的数据估计的多个协方差矩阵的近似联合对角化。我们进一步展示了如何将该方法扩展到自协方差矩阵,以及如何将适用于分段平稳数据的BSS方法应用于事件相关反应。我们通过使用模拟EEG以及测量的体感和经颅磁刺激(TMS)诱发的EEG比较了几种BSS方法。
在比较的方法中,MUCA对噪声、TMS伪迹和数据中的其他挑战具有最强的耐受性。对于测量的体感数据,MUCA和独立成分分析发现超过一半的估计成分相似。用几个输入数据集进行测试时,MUCA也很稳定。
MUCA基于简单的假设,结果表明MUCA对非理想数据具有鲁棒性。
事件相关反应和BSS是神经科学中有价值且常用的工具。正确设计的BSS是从非平稳事件相关数据中识别伪迹和神经过程的有效方法。