Richards Todd, Nagy William, Abbott Robert, Berninger Virginia
Integrated Brain Imaging Center, Department of Radiology, University of Washington, Seattle, USA.
School of Education, Seattle Pacific University, Seattle, USA.
J Syst Integr Neurosci. 2016;2(3). doi: 10.15761/JSIN.1000139. Epub 2016 Nov 10.
Typical oral and written language learners (controls) (5 girls, 4 boys) completed fMRI reading judgment tasks (sub-word grapheme-phoneme, word spelling, sentences with and without spelling foils, affixed words, sentences with and without affix foils, and multi-sentence). Analyses identified connectivity within and across adjacent levels (units) of language in reading: from subword to word to syntax in Set I and from word to syntax to multi-sentence in Set II). Typicals were compared to (a) students with dyslexia (6 girls, 10 boys) on the subword and word tasks in Set I related to levels of language impaired in dyslexia, and (b) students with oral and written language learning disability (OWL LD) (3 girls, 2 boys) on the morphology and syntax tasks in Set II, related to levels of language impaired in OWL LD. Results for typical language learners showed that adjacent levels of language in the reading brain share common and unique connectivity. The dyslexia group showed over-connectivity to a greater degree on the imaging tasks related to their levels of language impairments than the OWL LD group who showed under-connectivity to a greater degree than did the dyslexia group on the imaging tasks related to their levels of language impairment. Results for these students in grades 4 to 9 (ages 9 to 14) are discussed in reference to the contribution of patterns of connectivity across levels of language to understanding the nature of persisting dyslexia and dysgraphia despite early intervention.
典型的口语和书面语言学习者(对照组)(5名女孩,4名男孩)完成了功能磁共振成像阅读判断任务(次词素音素、单词拼写、有无拼写干扰项的句子、词缀词、有无词缀干扰项的句子以及多句)。分析确定了阅读中语言相邻层次(单位)内部和之间的连通性:在第一组中从次词到单词再到句法,在第二组中从单词到句法再到多句。将典型学习者与以下两组进行比较:(a)在第一组中与诵读困难所损害的语言层次相关的次词和单词任务上的诵读困难学生(6名女孩,10名男孩),以及(b)在第二组中与口语和书面语言学习障碍(OWL LD)所损害的语言层次相关的形态学和句法任务上的口语和书面语言学习障碍学生(3名女孩,2名男孩)。典型语言学习者的结果表明,阅读大脑中相邻的语言层次具有共同和独特的连通性。诵读困难组在与其语言损伤水平相关的成像任务上表现出比OWL LD组更大程度的过度连通性,而OWL LD组在与其语言损伤水平相关的成像任务上表现出比诵读困难组更大程度的连通不足。本文结合语言层次间连通性模式对理解尽管进行了早期干预但诵读困难和书写障碍仍然存在的本质的贡献,讨论了这些4至9年级(9至14岁)学生的结果。