Liptrott S, Bee P, Lovell K
European Institute of Oncology, Milan, Italy.
School of Nursing, Midwifery and Social Work, University of Manchester, Manchester, UK.
Eur J Cancer Care (Engl). 2018 Jan;27(1). doi: 10.1111/ecc.12643. Epub 2017 Jan 30.
Telephone-based interventions can increase accessibility to healthcare and are increasingly used as a convenient method of providing support. We conducted a systematic review of published literature reporting adult patients' perceptions of the acceptability of, and satisfaction with, telephone-based interventions during or post-treatment for cancer. Systematic searches identified 4,855 articles. Forty-eight articles describing 50 studies were included in the review. Three intervention categories were identified post hoc: (1) telephone follow-up in lieu of routine hospital follow-up, (2) telephone interventions for treatment side-effect monitoring and toxicity management supplementary to usual care, and (3) supplementary psycho-educational telephone interventions. Across studies, some consistent findings emerged. Positive perceptions emphasised the convenience of telephone interventions and increased accessibility to care. Conflicting perceptions of the quality of the support received, the impact of telecare on the patient-healthcare professional relationship and the need for such interventions emerged. In conclusion, the evidence base relating to patients' perceptions of telephone-based interventions is increasing. Interpretation of findings is currently limited by methodological limitations in the primary research. The instruments chosen to assess patient satisfaction quantitatively do not always reflect the patient-centred priorities that emerge from qualitative data. Subsequent research would benefit from well-designed qualitative studies and patient-centred outcome measures to ensure that the individuality of participants' positive and negative experiences is captured.
基于电话的干预措施可以提高医疗服务的可及性,并且越来越多地被用作提供支持的便捷方法。我们对已发表的文献进行了系统综述,这些文献报告了成年癌症患者在治疗期间或治疗后对基于电话的干预措施的可接受性和满意度。系统检索共识别出4855篇文章。本综述纳入了48篇描述50项研究的文章。事后确定了三类干预措施:(1)电话随访替代常规医院随访;(2)作为常规护理补充的用于治疗副作用监测和毒性管理的电话干预;(3)补充性心理教育电话干预。在各项研究中,出现了一些一致的发现。积极的看法强调了电话干预的便利性以及提高了医疗服务的可及性。对于所获得支持的质量、远程护理对患者与医护人员关系的影响以及此类干预措施的必要性,存在相互矛盾的看法。总之,与患者对基于电话的干预措施的看法相关的证据基础正在增加。目前,主要研究中的方法学局限性限制了对研究结果的解读。用于定量评估患者满意度的工具并不总是能反映定性数据中所体现的以患者为中心的优先事项。后续研究将受益于精心设计的定性研究和以患者为中心的结局指标,以确保能够捕捉参与者积极和消极体验的个体差异。