Shankar Priya, Chung Rainjade, Frank Deborah A
*Department of Pediatrics, Boston University School of Medicine, Boston, MA; †Dowling Ground, Boston Medical Center, Boston, MA.
J Dev Behav Pediatr. 2017 Feb/Mar;38(2):135-150. doi: 10.1097/DBP.0000000000000383.
Food Insecurity (FI) occurs in 21% of families with children and adolescents in the United States, but the potential developmental and behavioral implications of this prevalent social determinant of health have not been comprehensively elucidated. This systematic review aims to examine the association between FI and childhood developmental and behavioral outcomes in western industrialized countries.
This review provides a critical summary of 23 peer reviewed articles from developed countries on the associations between FI and adverse childhood developmental behavioral outcomes including early cognitive development, academic performance, inattention, externalizing behaviors, and depression in 4 groups-infants and toddlers, preschoolers, school age, and adolescents. Various approaches to measuring food insecurity are delineated. Potential confounding and mediating variables of this association are compared across studies. Alternate explanatory mechanisms of observed effects and need for further research are discussed.
This review demonstrates that household FI, even at marginal levels, is associated with children's behavioral, academic, and emotional problems from infancy to adolescence across western industrialized countries - even after controlling for confounders.
While the American Academy of Pediatrics already recommends routine screening for food insecurity during health maintenance visits, the evidence summarized here should encourage developmental behavioral health providers to screen for food insecurity in their practices and intervene when possible. Conversely, children whose families are identified as food insecure in primary care settings warrant enhanced developmental behavioral assessment and possible intervention.
在美国,21%有儿童和青少年的家庭存在粮食不安全状况,但这种普遍存在的健康社会决定因素对发育和行为的潜在影响尚未得到全面阐明。本系统综述旨在研究西方工业化国家中粮食不安全与儿童发育及行为结果之间的关联。
本综述对来自发达国家的23篇同行评议文章进行了批判性总结,这些文章涉及粮食不安全与不良儿童发育行为结果之间的关联,包括4个群体(婴幼儿、学龄前儿童、学龄儿童和青少年)的早期认知发展、学业成绩、注意力不集中、外化行为和抑郁。阐述了衡量粮食不安全的各种方法。对各研究中该关联的潜在混杂和中介变量进行了比较。讨论了观察到的效应的替代解释机制以及进一步研究的必要性。
本综述表明,在西方工业化国家,即使是边缘水平的家庭粮食不安全,也与儿童从婴儿期到青春期的行为、学业和情绪问题相关——即使在控制了混杂因素之后。
虽然美国儿科学会已经建议在健康维护访视期间对粮食不安全进行常规筛查,但此处总结的证据应促使发育行为健康提供者在其诊疗过程中筛查粮食不安全情况,并在可能时进行干预。相反,在初级保健环境中被确定为粮食不安全家庭的儿童需要加强发育行为评估并可能进行干预。