Chang Chien George C, Mekhail Nagy
Pain Management, Ventura County Medical Center, Ventura, CA, USA.
Center for Regenerative Medicine, Southern California University of Health Sciences, Whittier, CA, USA.
Neuromodulation. 2017 Oct;20(7):629-641. doi: 10.1111/ner.12568. Epub 2017 Feb 3.
Conventional dorsal column spinal cord stimulation (SCS) provides less than optimal pain relief for certain pain syndromes and anatomic pain distributions. Practitioners have sought to treat these challenging therapeutic areas with stimulation of alternate intraspinal targets.
To identify and systematically review the evidence for the value neuromodulating specific neuronal targets within the spinal canal to achieve relief of chronic pain.
A systematic literature search was conducted using PubMed for clinical trials published from 1966 to March 1, 2015 to identify neurostimulation studies that employed non-dorsal column intraspinal stimulation to achieve pain relief. Identified studies on such targeted intraspinal stimulation were reviewed and graded using Evidence Based Interventional Pain Medicine criteria.
We found a total of 13 articles that satisfied our search criteria on targeted, non-dorsal column intraspinal stimulation for pain. We identified five studies on neurostimulation of the cervicomedullary junction, six studies on neurostimulation of the dorsal root ganglion, two studies on the neurostimulation of the conus medullaris, unfortunately none was found on intraspinal nerve root stimulation.
The limitations of this review include the relative paucity of well-designed prospective studies on targeted SCS.
Clinical use of intraspinal neurostimulation is expanding at a very fast pace. Intraspinal stimulation of non-dorsal column targets may well be the future of neurostimulation as it provides new clinically significant neuromodulation of specific therapeutic targets that are not well or not easily addressed with conventional dorsal column SCS. In addition, they may avoid undesired stimulation induced paraesthesia, particularly in non-painful areas of the body.
传统的脊髓背柱刺激(SCS)对于某些疼痛综合征和解剖学疼痛分布提供的疼痛缓解效果欠佳。从业者们一直在寻求通过刺激脊髓内其他靶点来治疗这些具有挑战性的治疗领域。
识别并系统回顾椎管内特定神经元靶点神经调节以缓解慢性疼痛的价值的证据。
使用PubMed对1966年至2015年3月1日发表的临床试验进行系统文献检索,以识别采用非脊髓背柱刺激来实现疼痛缓解的神经刺激研究。对识别出的此类靶向脊髓内刺激的研究进行回顾,并根据循证介入性疼痛医学标准进行分级。
我们共找到13篇符合我们关于靶向性、非脊髓背柱脊髓内刺激治疗疼痛检索标准的文章。我们识别出5项关于颈髓交界处神经刺激的研究,6项关于背根神经节神经刺激的研究,2项关于圆锥神经刺激的研究,遗憾的是未找到关于脊髓神经根刺激的研究。
本综述的局限性包括针对靶向性脊髓刺激的设计良好的前瞻性研究相对较少。
脊髓内神经刺激的临床应用正在以非常快的速度扩展。脊髓内非背柱靶点的刺激很可能是神经刺激的未来发展方向,因为它提供了新的具有临床意义的特定治疗靶点的神经调节,而这些靶点是传统脊髓背柱SCS无法很好或不容易解决的。此外,它们可能避免不期望的刺激诱发的感觉异常,尤其是在身体的非疼痛区域。