Aucouturier Jean-Julien, Canonne Clément
CNRS Sound and Technology of Music and Sound (UMR9912, CNRS/IRCAM/UPMC), 1 Place Stravinsky, Paris France.
CNRS Sound and Technology of Music and Sound (UMR9912, CNRS/IRCAM/UPMC), 1 Place Stravinsky, Paris France.
Cognition. 2017 Apr;161:94-108. doi: 10.1016/j.cognition.2017.01.019. Epub 2017 Feb 3.
A recently emerging view in music cognition holds that music is not only social and participatory in its production, but also in its perception, i.e. that music is in fact perceived as the sonic trace of social relations between a group of real or virtual agents. While this view appears compatible with a number of intriguing music cognitive phenomena, such as the links between beat entrainment and prosocial behaviour or between strong musical emotions and empathy, direct evidence is lacking that listeners are at all able to use the acoustic features of a musical interaction to infer the affiliatory or controlling nature of an underlying social intention. We created a novel experimental situation in which we asked expert music improvisers to communicate 5 types of non-musical social intentions, such as being domineering, disdainful or conciliatory, to one another solely using musical interaction. Using a combination of decoding studies, computational and psychoacoustical analyses, we show that both musically-trained and non musically-trained listeners can recognize relational intentions encoded in music, and that this social cognitive ability relies, to a sizeable extent, on the information processing of acoustic cues of temporal and harmonic coordination that are not present in any one of the musicians' channels, but emerge from the dynamics of their interaction. By manipulating these cues in two-channel audio recordings and testing their impact on the social judgements of non-musician observers, we finally establish a causal relationship between the affiliation dimension of social behaviour and musical harmonic coordination on the one hand, and between the control dimension and musical temporal coordination on the other hand. These results provide novel mechanistic insights not only into the social cognition of musical interactions, but also into that of non-verbal interactions as a whole.
音乐认知领域最近出现的一种观点认为,音乐不仅在创作过程中具有社会性和参与性,在感知过程中亦是如此,即音乐实际上被视为一群真实或虚拟主体之间社会关系的声音痕迹。虽然这种观点似乎与一些有趣的音乐认知现象相契合,比如节拍同步与亲社会行为之间的联系,或者强烈的音乐情感与同理心之间的联系,但缺乏直接证据表明听众能够利用音乐互动的声学特征来推断潜在社会意图的亲和性或控制性。我们创造了一种新颖的实验情境,要求专业的音乐即兴演奏者仅通过音乐互动来相互传达5种非音乐的社会意图,比如专横、轻蔑或和解。通过结合解码研究、计算分析和心理声学分析,我们发现,无论是经过音乐训练的听众还是未经过音乐训练的听众,都能够识别音乐中编码的关系意图,而且这种社会认知能力在很大程度上依赖于对时间和和声协调的声学线索的信息处理,这些线索并非存在于任何一位音乐家的声道中,而是从他们互动的动态过程中浮现出来的。通过在双通道录音中操纵这些线索,并测试它们对非音乐家观察者社会判断的影响,我们最终建立了社会行为的亲和维度与音乐和声协调之间,以及控制维度与音乐时间协调之间的因果关系。这些结果不仅为音乐互动的社会认知,也为整个非语言互动的社会认知提供了新的机制性见解。