Hangoma Peter, Aakvik Arild, Robberstad Bjarne
Centre for International Health, University of Bergen, Bergen, Norway.
Unit of Health Economics, School of Public Health, University of Zambia, Lusaka, Zambia.
PLoS One. 2017 Feb 7;12(2):e0170995. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0170995. eCollection 2017.
Child health interventions were drastically scaled up in the period leading up to 2015 as countries aimed at meeting the 2015 target of the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs). MDGs were defined in terms of achieving improvements in average health. Significant improvements in average child health are documented, but evidence also points to rising inequality. It is important to investigate factors that drive the increasing disparities in order to inform the post-2015 development agenda of reducing inequality, as captured in the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). We investigated changes in socioeconomic inequality in stunting and fever in Zambia in 2007 and 2014. Unlike the huge literature that seeks to quantify the contribution of different determinants on the observed inequality at any given time, we quantify determinants of changes in inequality.
Data from the 2007 and 2014 waves of the Zambia Demographic and Health Survey (DHS) were utilized. Our sample consisted of children aged 0-5 years (n = 5,616 in 2007 and n = 12,714 in 2014). We employed multilevel models to assess the determinants of stunting and fever, which are two important child health indicators. The concentration index (CI) was used to measure the magnitude of inequality. Changes in inequality of stunting and fever were investigated using Oaxaca-type decomposition of the CI. In this approach, the change in the CI for stunting/fever is decomposed into changes in CI for each determinant and changes in the effect-measured as an elasticity-of each determinant on stunting/fever.
While average rates of stunting reduced in 2014 socioeconomic inequality in stunting increased significantly. Inequality in fever incidence also increased significantly, but average rates of fever did not reduce. The increase in the inequality (CI) of determinants accounted for the largest part (42.5%) of the increase in inequality of stunting, while the increase in the effect of determinants explained 35% of the increase. The determinants with the greatest total contribution (change in CI plus change in effect) to the increase in inequality of stunting were mother's height and weight, wealth, birth order, facility delivery, duration of breastfeeding, and maternal education. For fever, almost all (86%) the increase in inequality was accounted for by the increase in the effect of determinants of fever, while the distribution of determinants mattered less. The determinants with the greatest total contribution to the increase in inequality of fever were wealth, maternal education, birth order and breastfeeding duration. In the multilevel model, we found that the likelihood of a child being stunted or experiencing fever depends on the community in which they live.
To curb the increase in inequality of stunting and fever, policy may focus on improving levels of, and reducing inequality in, access to facility deliveries, maternal nutrition (which may be related to maternal weight and height), complementary feeding (for breastfed children), wealth, maternal education, and child care (related to birth order effects). Improving overall levels of these determinants contribute to the persistence of inequality if these determinants are unequally concentrated on the well off to begin with.
在2015年之前的时期,随着各国旨在实现千年发展目标(MDGs)的2015年目标,儿童健康干预措施得到了大幅扩大。千年发展目标是根据实现平均健康水平的改善来界定的。有记录显示平均儿童健康状况有显著改善,但证据也表明不平等现象在加剧。调查推动不平等现象加剧的因素很重要,以便为2015年后旨在减少不平等的发展议程提供信息,这在可持续发展目标(SDGs)中有所体现。我们调查了2007年和2014年赞比亚发育迟缓与发热方面社会经济不平等的变化。与大量试图量化不同决定因素在任何特定时间对观察到的不平等现象所做贡献的文献不同,我们量化不平等变化的决定因素。
利用了赞比亚人口与健康调查(DHS)2007年和2014年两轮的数据。我们的样本包括0至5岁的儿童(2007年为n = 5616,2014年为n = 12714)。我们采用多层次模型来评估发育迟缓和发热的决定因素,这是两个重要的儿童健康指标。集中指数(CI)用于衡量不平等程度。发育迟缓和发热不平等现象的变化通过集中指数的奥克塔维亚类型分解来进行调查。在这种方法中,发育迟缓/发热的集中指数变化被分解为每个决定因素的集中指数变化以及每个决定因素对发育迟缓/发热的影响变化(以弹性衡量)。
虽然2014年发育迟缓的平均发生率有所降低,但发育迟缓方面的社会经济不平等现象显著增加。发热发生率的不平等现象也显著增加,但发热的平均发生率并未降低。决定因素不平等程度的增加(集中指数)占发育迟缓不平等程度增加的最大部分(42.5%),而决定因素影响的增加解释了35%的增加。对发育迟缓不平等程度增加贡献最大(集中指数变化加上影响变化)的决定因素是母亲的身高和体重、财富、出生顺序、设施分娩、母乳喂养时长以及母亲教育程度。对于发热,几乎所有(86%)不平等现象的增加是由发热决定因素影响的增加导致的,而决定因素的分布影响较小。对发热不平等程度增加贡献最大的决定因素是财富、母亲教育程度、出生顺序和母乳喂养时长。在多层次模型中,我们发现儿童发育迟缓或发热的可能性取决于他们所居住的社区。
为遏制发育迟缓和发热不平等现象的加剧,政策可侧重于提高设施分娩、孕产妇营养(可能与母亲体重和身高有关)、补充喂养(针对母乳喂养儿童)、财富、母亲教育程度以及儿童照料(与出生顺序效应有关)的水平并减少这些方面的不平等。如果这些决定因素一开始就不平等地集中在富裕人群中,那么提高这些决定因素的总体水平会导致不平等现象持续存在。