Garip Gulcan, Morton Kate, Bridger Robert, Yardley Lucy
University of Derby Online Learning, Enterprise Centre, Derby, DE1 3LD UK.
Academic Unit of Psychology, Faculty of Social and Human Sciences, University of Southampton, Southampton, UK.
Pilot Feasibility Stud. 2017 Feb 6;3:6. doi: 10.1186/s40814-017-0122-2. eCollection 2017.
Overweight and obesity are a major concern that may influence the operational capacity of the UK Naval Service (NS). This study was conducted to evaluate the feasibility of trialling and implementing a modified web-based weight loss programme for overweight and obese NS personnel.
The feasibility of a web-based weight loss programme with minimal face to face support was evaluated using a non-randomised design, based on the and (RE-AIM) dimensions of a framework designed for analysing implementation of interventions in practice.
It was estimated that 6% ( = 58) of eligible NS personnel at recruitment sites were reached, based on personnel's expressions of interest to take part in the study. The potential efficacy of the intervention was evaluated by analysing participants' change in weight (kg) in the two groups. Forty-three participants were allocated to the intervention ( = 21) or control group ( = 22). Website usage was low, with 1.5 sessions accessed on average, over a 12-week follow-up. Changes in body weight over 12 weeks appeared to be observed for participants in the intervention group but not in the control group. The average weight loss observed in the intervention group (mean = -1.9 kg, SD = 2.1) appeared to reach significance, 95% CI [-2.8, -1.0], whereas no significant weight loss was apparent among control group participants (mean = -0.8 kg, SD = 3.8), 95% CI [-2.4, 0.8]. However, this feasibility study was not powered to test for within or group differences. Recruitment rates varied across five NS establishments invited to take part in the study, suggesting that the web-based weight loss programme was not adopted to the same extent across all bases. The online programme was not implemented as intended in terms of regular usage by participants and support provision by physical training instructors.
The results suggest that the intervention may warrant further investigation provided that engagement with the intervention by both staff and participants can be improved.
超重和肥胖是一个重大问题,可能会影响英国海军部队(NS)的作战能力。本研究旨在评估为超重和肥胖的NS人员试行和实施改良的基于网络的减肥计划的可行性。
基于为分析实践中干预措施实施情况而设计的框架的可达性、有效性、可接受性、实施性和维持性(RE-AIM)维度,采用非随机设计评估了一个几乎没有面对面支持的基于网络的减肥计划的可行性。
根据有兴趣参与研究的人员情况估计,招聘地点6%(n = 58)符合条件的NS人员参与了研究。通过分析两组参与者体重(千克)的变化来评估干预措施的潜在效果。43名参与者被分配到干预组(n = 21)或对照组(n = 22)。网站使用率较低,在12周的随访期间,平均访问次数为1.5次。干预组参与者在12周内的体重似乎有所变化,而对照组则没有。干预组观察到的平均体重减轻(均值 = -1.9千克,标准差 = 2.1)似乎具有统计学意义,95%置信区间为[-2.8, -1.0],而对照组参与者中没有明显的体重减轻(均值 = -0.8千克,标准差 = 3.8),95%置信区间为[-2.4, 0.8]。然而,这项可行性研究没有足够的效力来检验组内或组间差异。受邀参与研究的五个NS机构的招募率各不相同,这表明基于网络的减肥计划在所有基地并没有得到同等程度的采用。在线计划在参与者的定期使用和体育训练指导员的支持提供方面没有按预期实施。
结果表明,如果工作人员和参与者对干预措施的参与度能够提高,那么该干预措施可能值得进一步研究。