Steimer Andreas, Müller Michael, Schindler Kaspar
Department of Neurology, Inselspital\Bern University Hospital\University Bern, Bern, 3010, Switzerland.
Hum Brain Mapp. 2017 May;38(5):2509-2531. doi: 10.1002/hbm.23537. Epub 2017 Feb 16.
During the last 20 years, predictive modeling in epilepsy research has largely been concerned with the prediction of seizure events, whereas the inference of effective brain targets for resective surgery has received surprisingly little attention. In this exploratory pilot study, we describe a distributional clustering framework for the modeling of multivariate time series and use it to predict the effects of brain surgery in epilepsy patients. By analyzing the intracranial EEG, we demonstrate how patients who became seizure free after surgery are clearly distinguished from those who did not. More specifically, for 5 out of 7 patients who obtained seizure freedom (= Engel class I) our method predicts the specific collection of brain areas that got actually resected during surgery to yield a markedly lower posterior probability for the seizure related clusters, when compared to the resection of random or empty collections. Conversely, for 4 out of 5 Engel class III/IV patients who still suffer from postsurgical seizures, performance of the actually resected collection is not significantly better than performances displayed by random or empty collections. As the number of possible collections ranges into billions and more, this is a substantial contribution to a problem that today is still solved by visual EEG inspection. Apart from epilepsy research, our clustering methodology is also of general interest for the analysis of multivariate time series and as a generative model for temporally evolving functional networks in the neurosciences and beyond. Hum Brain Mapp 38:2509-2531, 2017. © 2017 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
在过去20年里,癫痫研究中的预测建模主要关注癫痫发作事件的预测,而对于切除性手术有效脑靶点的推断却出奇地未受到重视。在这项探索性的初步研究中,我们描述了一种用于多变量时间序列建模的分布聚类框架,并将其用于预测癫痫患者脑部手术的效果。通过分析颅内脑电图,我们展示了术后无癫痫发作的患者与未无癫痫发作的患者是如何被清晰区分的。更具体地说,在7名实现癫痫发作自由(=恩格尔I级)的患者中,有5名患者,与随机切除或空切除相比,我们的方法预测出手术中实际切除的特定脑区集合会使癫痫相关聚类的后验概率显著降低。相反,在5名仍患有术后癫痫的恩格尔III/IV级患者中,有4名患者,实际切除集合的表现并不比随机或空切除集合的表现显著更好。由于可能的集合数量达到数十亿甚至更多,这对一个目前仍通过目视脑电图检查来解决的问题做出了重大贡献。除了癫痫研究,我们的聚类方法对于多变量时间序列分析以及作为神经科学及其他领域中随时间演变的功能网络的生成模型也具有普遍意义。《人类大脑图谱》38:2509 - 2531, 2017。© 2017威利期刊公司。