Thijs Jochem
European Research Centre on Migration and Ethnic Relations (ERCOMER), Utrecht University, 3584 CH Utrecht, The Netherlands.
J Exp Child Psychol. 2017 Jun;158:46-63. doi: 10.1016/j.jecp.2017.01.005. Epub 2017 Feb 13.
Two vignette studies were conducted in which preadolescent children (Study 1: N=542; Study 2: N=137; aged 8-13years) evaluated the exclusion, for unknown reasons, of an immigrant minority child by a native majority peer (majority interethnic exclusion). Study 1 compared children's evaluations of majority interethnic exclusion with their evaluations of (majority and minority) intraethnic exclusion and minority interethnic exclusion, and Study 2 examined children's underlying explanations. Each study compared ethnic majority and ethnic minority respondents and examined the role of in-group bias for the former. Overall, both ethnic majority and ethnic minority respondents regarded majority interethnic exclusion more negatively than the other exclusion types (majority intraethnic, minority interethnic, and minority intraethnic). All children, but especially older minority respondents, were more likely to reject majority interethnic exclusion if they perceived it to be discriminatory (ethnicity based). Among the majority children, a strong in-group bias was associated with a weaker condemnation of majority interethnic exclusion, but this was not due to a larger tolerance of ethnicity-based discrimination. Biased majority children were also less likely to reject minority intraethnic exclusion, indicating an overall weaker concern for out-group victims. Taken together, the studies show that children are relatively negative about majority (prototypical) interethnic exclusion because it implies the possibility of ethnic discrimination, and they concur with previous evidence for a developmental increase in the awareness of discrimination in ethnic minority youths.
进行了两项案例研究,其中青春期前儿童(研究1:N = 542;研究2:N = 137;年龄在8至13岁)评估了本土多数群体同伴出于未知原因排斥一名移民少数群体儿童的情况(多数群体族际排斥)。研究1将儿童对多数群体族际排斥的评价与他们对(多数群体和少数群体)族内排斥以及少数群体族际排斥的评价进行了比较,研究2则考察了儿童的潜在解释。每项研究都比较了种族多数群体和少数群体的受访者,并研究了内群体偏见对前者的作用。总体而言,种族多数群体和少数群体的受访者都认为多数群体族际排斥比其他排斥类型(多数群体族内、少数群体族际和少数群体族内)更负面。所有儿童,尤其是年龄较大的少数群体受访者,如果他们认为多数群体族际排斥具有歧视性(基于种族),就更有可能拒绝这种排斥。在多数群体儿童中,强烈的内群体偏见与对多数群体族际排斥的较弱谴责相关,但这并非由于对基于种族的歧视有更大的容忍度。有偏见的多数群体儿童也不太可能拒绝少数群体族内排斥,这表明他们对群体外受害者的总体关注较弱。综合来看,这些研究表明,儿童对多数群体(典型的)族际排斥相对负面,因为这意味着种族歧视的可能性,并且他们与之前关于少数族裔青少年对歧视意识发展性增强的证据一致。