Schwab Nicholas, Schneider-Hohendorf Tilman, Melzer Nico, Cutter Gary, Wiendl Heinz
From the Department of Neurology (N.S., T.S.-H., N.M., H.W.), University of Münster, Germany; and University of Alabama School of Public Health (G.C.), Birmingham.
Neurology. 2017 Mar 21;88(12):1197-1205. doi: 10.1212/WNL.0000000000003739. Epub 2017 Feb 22.
Progressive multifocal leukoencephalopathy (PML) associated with natalizumab treatment continues to be a severe problem of clinically successful therapy. This is an update of risk stratification developments and discusses the current approach to depict and calculate PML incidence and PML risk. (1) PML incidence and resulting risk used in today's clinical practice are potentially outdated and the risk for patients with prior immunosuppression might have been underestimated. (2) Risk stratification according to treatment duration epochs likely suggests lower risk due to patients stopping treatment within a given epoch. PML incidence within the complete treatment epoch is statistically lowered due to the fact that patients at the beginning of an epoch presumably have a lower PML risk than the patients at the end. Periodic risk is not accurate in assessing risk for long treatment durations. (3) The JC virus (JCV) serostatus risk factor has low specificity concerning PML prediction and anti-JCV seroconversion during treatment with natalizumab further lowers its specificity over time. Specificity of the risk factor treatment duration varies depending on the average treatment duration and the number of short-term patients. These short-term patients reduce overall average treatment duration and thus enhance the specificity of the risk factor and reduce overall PML incidence. It is also suggested that short-term natalizumab patients are exclusively non-PML, even though they might still develop PML. Clinicians have to consider the cumulative risk of patients to stratify efficiently.
与那他珠单抗治疗相关的进行性多灶性白质脑病(PML)仍然是临床成功治疗中的一个严重问题。本文是风险分层进展的最新情况,并讨论了描述和计算PML发病率及PML风险的当前方法。(1)当今临床实践中使用的PML发病率及由此产生的风险可能过时,既往免疫抑制患者的风险可能被低估。(2)根据治疗持续时间阶段进行风险分层可能显示风险较低,因为患者在给定阶段内停止治疗。由于在一个阶段开始时的患者PML风险可能低于该阶段结束时的患者,所以整个治疗阶段内的PML发病率在统计学上降低。对于长治疗持续时间,定期风险评估不准确。(3)JC病毒(JCV)血清学状态风险因素在预测PML方面特异性较低,并且在使用那他珠单抗治疗期间抗JCV血清转化会随着时间进一步降低其特异性。风险因素治疗持续时间的特异性因平均治疗持续时间和短期患者数量而异。这些短期患者降低了总体平均治疗持续时间,从而提高了风险因素的特异性并降低了总体PML发病率。还表明,短期使用那他珠单抗的患者尽管仍可能发生PML,但完全不会发生PML。临床医生必须考虑患者的累积风险以进行有效分层。