Marshall-Pescini Sarah, Virányi Zsófia, Kubinyi Enikő, Range Friederike
Comparative Cognition, Messerli Research Institute, University of Veterinary Medicine, Vienna, Medical University of Vienna, University of ViennaVienna, Austria; Wolf Science CentreErnstbrunn, Austria.
Department of Ethology, Eötvös Loránd UniversityBudapest, Hungary; MTA-ELTE Comparative Ethology Research GroupBudapest, Hungary.
Front Psychol. 2017 Feb 9;8:180. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2017.00180. eCollection 2017.
Wolves have been shown to be better in independent problem-solving tasks than dogs, however it is unclear whether cognitive or motivational factors underlie such differences. In a number of species problem solving has been linked to both persistence in exploration and neophobia, suggesting both these aspects may underlie dog-wolf differences in problem solving. Indeed adult wolves have been shown to be more likely to approach a novel object and more persistent in their investigation of it, but also slower in making contact with it and more fearful of it than dogs. In the current study we investigated potential differences in equally-raised dogs' and wolves' explorative and neophobic behaviors in a novel environment and with novel objects at 5, 6, and 8 weeks of age. Results showed that wolves were more persistent in exploring both the environment and the objects than dogs, and this was the case at all ages. There were no differences in the frequency of fear-related behaviors and time spent in proximity to humans. Stress-related behaviors were similarly expressed at 5 and 6 weeks, although wolves showed a higher frequency of such behaviors at 8 weeks. Overall, results with puppies confirm those with adult animals: wolves appear to be more explorative than dogs. Such motivational differences need to be taken into account when comparing dogs and wolves in cognitive tasks.
研究表明,狼在独立解决问题的任务中比狗表现得更好,然而尚不清楚认知因素还是动机因素导致了这种差异。在许多物种中,解决问题与探索的持续性和新事物恐惧都有关联,这表明这两个方面可能是狗和狼在解决问题上存在差异的原因。事实上,成年狼已被证明更有可能接近新物体,并在对其进行调查时更具持续性,但与狗相比,它们与新物体接触的速度较慢,且对新物体更恐惧。在本研究中,我们调查了在相同环境下饲养的狗和狼在5周、6周和8周龄时,面对新环境和新物体时探索行为和新事物恐惧行为的潜在差异。结果表明,狼在探索环境和物体方面比狗更具持续性,且在所有年龄段都是如此。与恐惧相关的行为频率以及与人类接近的时间没有差异。5周和6周龄时,与压力相关的行为表现相似,不过8周龄时狼表现出此类行为的频率更高。总体而言,幼犬的研究结果与成年动物的一致:狼似乎比狗更具探索性。在认知任务中比较狗和狼时,需要考虑到这种动机差异。