Waltho Daniel, Hatchell Alexandra, Thoma Achilleas
Ottawa and Hamilton, Ontario, Canada.
From the Department of Medicine, Faculty of Medicine, University of Ottawa; and the Division of Plastic Surgery and the Surgical Outcomes Research Center, Department of Surgery, and the Departments of Clinical Epidemiology and Biostatistics and Medicine, McMaster University.
Plast Reconstr Surg. 2017 Mar;139(3):638e-648e. doi: 10.1097/PRS.0000000000003059.
Gynecomastia is a common deformity of the male breast, where certain cases warrant surgical management. There are several surgical options, which vary depending on the breast characteristics. To guide surgical management, several classification systems for gynecomastia have been proposed.
A systematic review was performed to (1) identify all classification systems for the surgical management of gynecomastia, and (2) determine the adequacy of these classification systems to appropriately categorize the condition for surgical decision-making.
The search yielded 1012 articles, and 11 articles were included in the review. Eleven classification systems in total were ascertained, and a total of 10 unique features were identified: (1) breast size, (2) skin redundancy, (3) breast ptosis, (4) tissue predominance, (5) upper abdominal laxity, (6) breast tuberosity, (7) nipple malposition, (8) chest shape, (9) absence of sternal notch, and (10) breast skin elasticity. On average, classification systems included two or three of these features. Breast size and ptosis were the most commonly included features.
Based on their review of the current classification systems, the authors believe the ideal classification system should be universal and cater to all causes of gynecomastia; be surgically useful and easy to use; and should include a comprehensive set of clinically appropriate patient-related features, such as breast size, breast ptosis, tissue predominance, and skin redundancy. None of the current classification systems appears to fulfill these criteria.
男性乳房肥大是男性乳房常见的畸形,某些病例需要手术治疗。有几种手术选择,具体取决于乳房特征。为指导手术治疗,已提出了几种男性乳房肥大的分类系统。
进行了一项系统评价,以(1)确定所有用于男性乳房肥大手术治疗的分类系统,以及(2)确定这些分类系统对该病症进行适当分类以用于手术决策的充分性。
检索得到1012篇文章,其中11篇纳入本评价。总共确定了11种分类系统,共识别出10个独特特征:(1)乳房大小,(2)皮肤冗余,(3)乳房下垂,(4)组织优势,(5)上腹部松弛,(6)乳房结节,(7)乳头位置异常,(8)胸廓形状,(9)无胸骨切迹,以及(10)乳房皮肤弹性。平均而言,分类系统包括其中两到三个特征。乳房大小和下垂是最常包含的特征。
基于对当前分类系统的评价,作者认为理想的分类系统应具有普遍性,适用于男性乳房肥大的所有病因;在手术中有用且易于使用;并且应包括一组全面的与患者相关的临床适当特征,如乳房大小、乳房下垂、组织优势和皮肤冗余。目前的分类系统似乎均未满足这些标准。