Vijayakumar Nandita, Cheng Theresa W, Pfeifer Jennifer H
Department of Psychology, University of Oregon, Eugene, OR 97403, USA.
Department of Psychology, University of Oregon, Eugene, OR 97403, USA.
Neuroimage. 2017 Jun;153:359-368. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2017.02.050. Epub 2017 Feb 21.
Given the recent surge in functional neuroimaging studies on social exclusion, the current study employed activation likelihood estimation (ALE) based meta-analyses to identify brain regions that have consistently been implicated across different experimental paradigms used to investigate exclusion. We also examined the neural correlates underlying Cyberball, the most commonly used paradigm to study exclusion, as well as differences in exclusion-related activation between developing (7-18 years of age, from pre-adolescence up to late adolescence) and emerging adult (broadly defined as undergraduates, including late adolescence and young adulthood) samples. Results revealed involvement of the bilateral medial prefrontal and posterior cingulate cortices, right precuneus and left ventrolateral prefrontal cortex across the different paradigms used to examine social exclusion; similar activation patterns were identified when restricting the analysis to Cyberball studies. Investigations into age-related effects revealed that ventrolateral prefrontal activations identified in the full sample were driven by (i.e. present in) developmental samples, while medial prefrontal activations were driven by emerging adult samples. In addition, the right ventral striatum was implicated in exclusion, but only in developmental samples. Subtraction analysis revealed significantly greater activation likelihood in striatal and ventrolateral prefrontal clusters in the developmental samples as compared to emerging adults, though the opposite contrast failed to identify any significant regions. Findings integrate the knowledge accrued from functional neuroimaging studies on social exclusion to date, highlighting involvement of lateral prefrontal regions implicated in regulation and midline structures involved in social cognitive and self-evaluative processes across experimental paradigms and ages, as well as limbic structures in developing samples specifically.
鉴于近期关于社会排斥的功能性神经影像学研究激增,本研究采用基于激活可能性估计(ALE)的元分析来识别在用于研究排斥的不同实验范式中一直涉及的脑区。我们还研究了用于研究排斥的最常用范式——赛博球(Cyberball)背后的神经关联,以及发育阶段(7至18岁,从青春期前到青春期后期)和新兴成年人(广义定义为本科生,包括青春期后期和青年期)样本之间与排斥相关的激活差异。结果显示,在用于检验社会排斥的不同范式中,双侧内侧前额叶和后扣带回皮质、右侧楔前叶和左侧腹外侧前额叶皮质均有参与;当将分析限制在赛博球研究时,也发现了类似的激活模式。对年龄相关效应的调查显示,全样本中确定的腹外侧前额叶激活由发育样本驱动(即存在于发育样本中),而内侧前额叶激活由新兴成年人样本驱动。此外,右侧腹侧纹状体与排斥有关,但仅在发育样本中。减法分析显示,与新兴成年人相比,发育样本中纹状体和腹外侧前额叶簇的激活可能性显著更大,尽管相反的对比未能识别出任何显著区域。研究结果整合了迄今为止从关于社会排斥的功能性神经影像学研究中积累的知识,突出了外侧前额叶区域参与调节,以及中线结构参与跨实验范式和年龄的社会认知和自我评估过程,特别是在发育样本中的边缘结构。