Arriola Kimberly Jacob
J Health Care Poor Underserved. 2017;28(1):30-45. doi: 10.1353/hpu.2017.0005.
There are clear and compelling racial disparities in access to renal transplant, which is the therapy of choice for many patients with end stage renal disease. This paper conceptualizes the role of racism (i.e., internalized, personally-mediated, and institutionalized) in creating and perpetuating these disparities at multiple levels of the social ecology by integrating two often-cited theories in the literature. Internalized racism is manifested at the intrapersonal level when, for example, African American patients devalue their self-worth, thereby not pursuing the most aggressive treatment available. Personally-mediated racism is manifested at the interpersonal level when, for example, physicians exhibit unconscious race bias that impacts their treatment decisions. One example of institutionalized racism being manifested at the institutional, community, and public policy levels is the longstanding existence of racial residential segregation and empirically established links between neighborhood racial composition and dialysis facility-level transplantation rates. This paper concludes with clinical, research, and policy recommendations.
在获得肾移植方面存在明显且令人信服的种族差异,而肾移植是许多终末期肾病患者的首选治疗方法。本文通过整合文献中经常引用的两种理论,阐述了种族主义(即内化的、个人介导的和制度化的)在社会生态的多个层面上造成并延续这些差异所起的作用。内化的种族主义在个人层面表现为,例如非裔美国患者贬低自己的自我价值,从而不寻求可用的最积极治疗。个人介导的种族主义在人际层面表现为,例如医生表现出无意识的种族偏见,这会影响他们的治疗决策。制度化的种族主义在机构、社区和公共政策层面表现的一个例子是种族居住隔离的长期存在,以及经实证确定的社区种族构成与透析设施层面移植率之间的联系。本文最后提出了临床、研究和政策建议。