Martin Andrea E, Doumas Leonidas A A
Department of Psychology, School of Philosophy, Psychology, and Language Sciences, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, United Kingdom.
Department of Psychology of Language, Max Planck Institute for Psycholinguistics, Nijmegen, The Netherlands.
PLoS Biol. 2017 Mar 2;15(3):e2000663. doi: 10.1371/journal.pbio.2000663. eCollection 2017 Mar.
Biological systems often detect species-specific signals in the environment. In humans, speech and language are species-specific signals of fundamental biological importance. To detect the linguistic signal, human brains must form hierarchical representations from a sequence of perceptual inputs distributed in time. What mechanism underlies this ability? One hypothesis is that the brain repurposed an available neurobiological mechanism when hierarchical linguistic representation became an efficient solution to a computational problem posed to the organism. Under such an account, a single mechanism must have the capacity to perform multiple, functionally related computations, e.g., detect the linguistic signal and perform other cognitive functions, while, ideally, oscillating like the human brain. We show that a computational model of analogy, built for an entirely different purpose-learning relational reasoning-processes sentences, represents their meaning, and, crucially, exhibits oscillatory activation patterns resembling cortical signals elicited by the same stimuli. Such redundancy in the cortical and machine signals is indicative of formal and mechanistic alignment between representational structure building and "cortical" oscillations. By inductive inference, this synergy suggests that the cortical signal reflects structure generation, just as the machine signal does. A single mechanism-using time to encode information across a layered network-generates the kind of (de)compositional representational hierarchy that is crucial for human language and offers a mechanistic linking hypothesis between linguistic representation and cortical computation.
生物系统常常能检测出环境中特定物种的信号。对人类而言,言语和语言是具有根本生物学重要性的特定物种信号。为了检测语言信号,人类大脑必须从按时间分布的一系列感知输入中形成层次化表征。这种能力背后的机制是什么?一种假设是,当层次化语言表征成为解决生物体面临的计算问题的有效方案时,大脑重新利用了一种现有的神经生物学机制。按照这种说法,单一机制必须具备执行多种功能相关计算的能力,例如检测语言信号并执行其他认知功能,同时,理想情况下,要像人类大脑一样振荡。我们表明,一个为完全不同的目的——学习关系推理而构建的类比计算模型,能够处理句子、表征其含义,并且至关重要的是,呈现出类似于由相同刺激引发的皮层信号的振荡激活模式。皮层信号与机器信号中的这种冗余表明了表征结构构建与“皮层”振荡之间的形式和机制一致性。通过归纳推理,这种协同作用表明皮层信号正如机器信号一样反映结构生成。单一机制——利用时间在分层网络中编码信息——生成了对人类语言至关重要的那种(解)组合表征层次结构,并为语言表征与皮层计算之间提供了一个机制性的联系假设。