Bello Aminu K, Molzahn Anita E, Girard Louis P, Osman Mohamed A, Okpechi Ikechi G, Glassford Jodi, Thompson Stephanie, Keely Erin, Liddy Clare, Manns Braden, Jinda Kailash, Klarenbach Scott, Hemmelgarn Brenda, Tonelli Marcello
Department of Medicine, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.
Faculty of Nursing, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta, Canada.
BMJ Open. 2017 Mar 2;7(3):e014784. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2016-014784.
We assessed stakeholder perceptions on the use of an electronic consultation system (e-Consult) to improve the delivery of kidney care in Alberta. We aim to identify acceptability, barriers and facilitators to the use of an e-Consult system for ambulatory kidney care delivery.
This was a qualitative focus group study using a thematic analysis design. Eight focus groups were held in four locations in the province of Alberta, Canada. In total, there were 72 participants in two broad stakeholder categories: patients (including patients' relatives) and providers (including primary care physicians, nephrologists, other care providers and policymakers).
The e-Consult system was generally acceptable across all stakeholder groups. The key barriers identified were length of time required for referring physicians to complete the e-Consult due to lack of integration with current electronic medical records, and concerns that increased numbers of requests might overwhelm nephrologists and lead to a delayed response or an unsustainable system. The key facilitators identified were potential improvement of care coordination, dissemination of best practice through an educational platform, comprehensive data to make decisions without the need for face-to-face consultation, timely feedback to primary care providers, timeliness/reduced delays for patients' rapid triage and identification of cases needing urgent care and improved access to information to facilitate decision-making in patient care.
Stakeholder perceptions regarding the e-Consult system were favourable, and the key barriers and facilitators identified will be considered in design and implementation of an acceptable and sustainable electronic consultation system for kidney care delivery.
我们评估了利益相关者对使用电子会诊系统(e-Consult)改善艾伯塔省肾脏护理服务的看法。我们旨在确定使用e-Consult系统进行门诊肾脏护理服务的可接受性、障碍和促进因素。
这是一项采用主题分析设计的定性焦点小组研究。在加拿大艾伯塔省的四个地点举行了八次焦点小组会议。共有来自两类广泛利益相关者的72名参与者:患者(包括患者亲属)和提供者(包括初级保健医生、肾病学家、其他护理提供者和政策制定者)。
e-Consult系统在所有利益相关者群体中总体上是可接受的。确定的主要障碍是由于与当前电子病历缺乏整合,转诊医生完成e-Consult所需的时间较长,以及担心请求数量增加可能使肾病学家不堪重负,导致响应延迟或系统不可持续。确定的主要促进因素包括护理协调的潜在改善、通过教育平台传播最佳实践、无需面对面咨询即可做出决策的综合数据、及时反馈给初级保健提供者、患者快速分诊的及时性/减少延迟以及识别需要紧急护理的病例,以及改善信息获取以促进患者护理决策。
利益相关者对e-Consult系统的看法是积极的,在设计和实施一个可接受且可持续的肾脏护理电子会诊系统时,将考虑所确定的主要障碍和促进因素。