Oxley C J, Dennick R, Batchelor P
GDP, 4 Manor Farm Lane, Drayton, Market Harborough, LE16 8SW.
Head of Medical Education, University of Nottingham.
Br Dent J. 2017 Mar 10;222(5):391-395. doi: 10.1038/sj.bdj.2017.226.
Background There have been anecdotal concerns that the skill mix of recently qualified graduates is very different to those qualifying several years ago, in particular that the clinical skills on qualification are less. If true, such changes may have ramifications for providers of undergraduate training, postgraduate training, particularly at foundation training level, and ultimately the public.Aim The aim of this study was to assess changes in perceived standards of newly qualified graduates as reported by foundation trainers.Method A cross-sectional survey was conducted using a self-completed internet-based survey tool sent to all foundation trainers (FTs) in England, Northern Ireland and Wales.Results A total of 312 responses were obtained covering all postgraduate deaneries. There was mixed opinion regarding standards of new graduates, with 51% reporting that the overall standard of those entering foundation training was 'unsatisfactory'. Standards in key clinical areas were considered unsatisfactory by large proportions of respondents. Eighty-five percent considered standards to be unsatisfactory in 'crown and bridge', 75% in 'extraction of teeth', 74% in endodontics, 67% in removable prosthodontics, and 62% in treatment planning. Experienced trainers identified a decline in standards in particular clinical areas.Conclusions A large proportion of foundation trainers consider the current standard of new graduates to be unsatisfactory for entering foundation training. There are a number of key clinical areas of concern and a perception of declining standards.
一直有传闻称,刚毕业的合格毕业生的技能组合与几年前毕业的学生有很大不同,尤其是他们毕业时的临床技能有所下降。如果情况属实,这种变化可能会对本科培训、研究生培训的提供者产生影响,尤其是基础培训层面,最终还会影响公众。
本研究的目的是评估基础培训导师报告的新合格毕业生感知标准的变化。
采用基于网络的自填式调查工具,对英格兰、北爱尔兰和威尔士的所有基础培训导师进行横断面调查。
共获得312份涵盖所有研究生培训地区的回复。对于新毕业生的标准,意见不一,51%的人报告称进入基础培训的学生总体标准“不令人满意”。很大比例的受访者认为关键临床领域的标准不令人满意。85%的人认为“冠桥修复”的标准不令人满意,75%的人认为“拔牙”的标准不令人满意,74%的人认为牙髓病学的标准不令人满意,67%的人认为可摘局部义齿修复的标准不令人满意,62%的人认为治疗计划的标准不令人满意。经验丰富的培训师指出特定临床领域的标准有所下降。
很大比例的基础培训导师认为新毕业生目前进入基础培训的标准不令人满意。存在一些关键的临床关注领域,且有标准下降的看法。