Freye E, Buhl R, Ciaramelli F
Dept. of Central Diagnostics, University Clinic of Psychiatry, Essen, F.R.G.
NIDA Res Monogr. 1986;75:551-4.
Amplitude changes of event-related sensory potentials (SEP's) present objective measurements for the evaluation of pain perception in man. Alfentanil, an opioid with dominant binding to the mu-receptor was given in graded doses (5-, 10- micrograms/kg) to volunteers. Nalbuphine, an opioid with reported kappa-agonist activity, was given in graded doses (100-, 500-, 1000- micrograms/kg) to another group i.v. Both groups were also exposed to progressively increased electrical stimulations (mA) in order to determine tolerance threshold before and after drug administration. In the alfentanil group (n = 5) there was a dose- related decrease of the amplitude of the early N20-peak. The late N100-peak was not, however, affected. This correlated closely (r = 0.87) with a naloxone-reversible increase of tolerance to electrical current. In the nalbuphine group (n = 15), there was a dose-related, naloxone non-reversible reduction of amplitude of the late N100-peak which showed a good correlation (r = 0.9) with an increase in current threshold. As the early evoked potentials are primarily generated in the pontine-thalamic region, it is suggested that the mode of action of alfentanil resembles that of a blockade of sensory impulses. The latter takes place before impulses are transmitted to more rostrally located CNS structures which are responsible for pain identification. The late evoked potential affected by nalbuphine indicates an activity on thalamo-cortical projection sites which are involved in subjects' cognitive activities. Kappa-ligands, therefore, seem to exert a different mode of action than mu-opioids, which results in a modulation of the negative emotional response associated with pain, rather than an attenuation of pain impulses.
事件相关感觉电位(SEP)的振幅变化为评估人类疼痛感知提供了客观测量方法。向志愿者分次给予阿芬太尼,一种主要与μ受体结合的阿片类药物,剂量为(5、10微克/千克)。向另一组静脉注射纳布啡,一种据报道具有κ激动剂活性的阿片类药物,剂量为(100、500、1000微克/千克)。两组还接受逐渐增加的电刺激(毫安),以确定给药前后的耐受阈值。在阿芬太尼组(n = 5)中,早期N20波峰的振幅呈剂量相关下降。然而,晚期N100波峰未受影响。这与纳洛酮可逆的电流耐受性增加密切相关(r = 0.87)。在纳布啡组(n = 15)中,晚期N100波峰的振幅呈剂量相关、纳洛酮不可逆的降低,这与电流阈值增加具有良好的相关性(r = 0.9)。由于早期诱发电位主要在脑桥 - 丘脑区域产生,提示阿芬太尼的作用方式类似于感觉冲动的阻断。这种阻断发生在冲动传递到更靠上的负责疼痛识别的中枢神经系统结构之前。受纳布啡影响的晚期诱发电位表明其对丘脑 - 皮质投射部位有作用,这些部位参与受试者的认知活动。因此κ配体似乎发挥了与μ阿片类药物不同的作用方式,导致与疼痛相关的负面情绪反应得到调节,而不是疼痛冲动的减弱。