Parillaud Vincent R, Lornet Guillaume, Monnet Yann, Privat Anne-Laure, Haddad Andrei T, Brochard Vanessa, Bekaert Amaury, de Chanville Camille Baudesson, Hirsch Etienne C, Combadière Christophe, Hunot Stéphane, Lobsiger Christian S
Inserm, U 1127, F-75013, Paris, France.
CNRS, UMR 7225, F-75013, Paris, France.
J Neuroinflammation. 2017 Mar 21;14(1):60. doi: 10.1186/s12974-017-0830-9.
Evidence from mice suggests that brain infiltrating immune cells contribute to neurodegeneration, and we previously identified a deleterious lymphocyte infiltration in Parkinson's disease mice. However, this remains controversial for monocytes, due to artifact-prone techniques used to distinguish them from microglia. Our aim was to reassess this open question, by taking advantage of the recent recognition that chemokine receptors CCR2 and CX3CR1 can differentiate between inflammatory monocytes and microglia, enabling to test whether CCR2 monocytes infiltrate the brain during dopaminergic (DA) neurodegeneration and whether they contribute to neuronal death. This revealed unexpected insights into possible regulation of monocyte-attracting CCL2 induction.
We used acute 1-methyl-4-phenyl-1,2,3,6-tetrahydropyridine (MPTP) mice and assessed monocyte infiltration by combining laser microdissection-guided chemokine RNA profiling of the substantia nigra (SN) with immunohistochemistry and CCR2-GFP reporter mice. To determine contribution to neuronal loss, we used CCR2-deletion and CCL2-overexpression, to reduce and increase CCR2 monocyte infiltration, and CX3CR1-deletion to assess a potential implication in CCL2 regulation.
Nigral chemokine profiling revealed early CCL2/7/12-CCR2 axis induction, suggesting monocyte infiltration in MPTP mice. CCL2 protein showed early peak induction in nigral astrocytes, while CCR2-GFP mice revealed early but limited nigral monocyte infiltration. However, blocking infiltration by CCR2 deletion did not influence DA neuronal loss. In contrast, transgenic astrocytic CCL2 over-induction increased CCR2 monocyte infiltration and DA neuronal loss in MPTP mice. Surprisingly, CCL2 over-induction was also detected in MPTP intoxicated CX3CR1-deleted mice, which are known to present increased DA neuronal loss. Importantly, CX3CR1/CCL2 double-deletion suggested that increased neurotoxicity was driven by astrocytic CCL2 over-induction.
We show that CCR2 monocytes infiltrate the affected CNS, but at the level observed in acute MPTP mice, this does not contribute to DA neuronal loss. In contrast, the underlying astrocytic CCL2 induction seemed to be tightly controled, as already moderate CCL2 over-induction led to increased neurotoxicity in MPTP mice, likely due to the increased CCR2 monocyte infiltration. Importantly, we found evidence suggesting that during DA neurodegeneration, this control was mediated by microglial CX3CR1 signaling, which protects against such neurotoxic CCL2 over-induction by astrocytes, thus hinting at an endogenous mechanism to limit neurotoxic effects of the CCL2-CCR2 axis.
小鼠实验证据表明,浸润大脑的免疫细胞会导致神经退行性变,我们之前在帕金森病小鼠中发现了有害的淋巴细胞浸润。然而,由于用于区分单核细胞与小胶质细胞的技术容易产生假象,单核细胞在这方面仍存在争议。我们的目的是通过利用最近的认识,即趋化因子受体CCR2和CX3CR1可以区分炎性单核细胞和小胶质细胞,来重新评估这个悬而未决的问题,从而能够测试CCR2单核细胞在多巴胺能(DA)神经退行性变期间是否浸润大脑以及它们是否导致神经元死亡。这揭示了关于单核细胞趋化因子CCL2诱导可能调控的意外见解。
我们使用急性1-甲基-4-苯基-1,2,3,6-四氢吡啶(MPTP)小鼠,并通过将激光显微切割引导的黑质趋化因子RNA谱分析与免疫组织化学以及CCR2-GFP报告基因小鼠相结合来评估单核细胞浸润。为了确定对神经元损失的影响,我们使用CCR2缺失和CCL2过表达来减少和增加CCR2单核细胞浸润,并使用CX3CR1缺失来评估其在CCL2调控中的潜在作用。
黑质趋化因子谱分析显示早期CCL2/7/12-CCR2轴诱导,提示MPTP小鼠中有单核细胞浸润。CCL2蛋白在黑质星形胶质细胞中显示早期峰值诱导,而CCR2-GFP小鼠显示早期但有限的黑质单核细胞浸润。然而,通过CCR2缺失阻断浸润并不影响DA神经元损失。相反,转基因星形胶质细胞CCL2过度诱导增加了MPTP小鼠中CCR2单核细胞浸润和DA神经元损失。令人惊讶的是,在MPTP中毒的CX3CR1缺失小鼠中也检测到CCL2过度诱导,已知这些小鼠会出现DA神经元损失增加。重要的是,CX3CR1/CCL2双缺失表明神经毒性增加是由星形胶质细胞CCL2过度诱导驱动的。
我们表明CCR2单核细胞浸润受影响的中枢神经系统,但在急性MPTP小鼠中观察到的水平上,这并不导致DA神经元损失。相反,潜在的星形胶质细胞CCL2诱导似乎受到严格控制,因为已经适度的CCL2过度诱导会导致MPTP小鼠神经毒性增加,可能是由于CCR2单核细胞浸润增加。重要的是,我们发现证据表明在DA神经退行性变期间,这种控制是由小胶质细胞CX3CR1信号介导的,它可防止星形胶质细胞这种神经毒性CCL2过度诱导,从而暗示了一种限制CCL2-CCR2轴神经毒性作用的内源性机制。