Mutale Wilbroad, Masoso Chisala, Mwanza Bisalom, Chirwa Cindy, Mwaba Lasidah, Siwale Zumbe, Lamisa Barbara, Musatwe Dennis, Chilengi Roma
Department of Public Health, University of Zambia School of Medicine, Lusaka, Zambia.
Centre for Infectious Disease Research in Zambia (CIDRZ), Lusaka, Zambia.
BMC Public Health. 2017 Mar 23;17(1):277. doi: 10.1186/s12889-017-4187-x.
The United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) has adopted an approach entitled Community Conversation (CC) to improve community engagement in addressing health challenges. CCs are based on Paulo Freire's transformative communication approach, in which communities pose problems and critically examine their everyday life experiences through discussion. We adopted this approach to engage communities in maternal and newborn health discussions in three rural districts of Zambia, with the aim of developing community-generated interventions.
Sixty (60) CCs were held in three target districts, covering a total of 20 health facilities. Communities were purposively selected in each district to capture a range of rural and peri-urban areas at varying distances from health facilities. Conversations were held four times in each community between May and September 2014. All conversations were digitally recorded and later transcribed. NVivo version 10 was used for data analysis.
The major barriers to accessing maternal health services included geography, limited infrastructure, lack of knowledge, shortage of human resources and essential commodities, and insufficient involvement of male partners. From the demand side, a lack of information and misconceptions, and, from the supply side, inadequately trained health workers with poor attitudes, negatively affected access to maternal health services in target districts either directly or indirectly. At least 17 of 20 communities suggested solutions to these challenges, including targeted community sensitisation on the importance of safe motherhood, family planning and prevention of teenage pregnancy. Community members and key stakeholders committed time and resources to address these challenges with minimal external support.
We successfully applied the CC approach to explore maternal health challenges in three rural districts of Zambia. CCs functioned as an advocacy platform to facilitate direct engagement with key decision makers within the community and to align priorities while incorporating community views. There was a general lack of knowledge about safe motherhood and family planning in all three districts. However, other problems were unique to health facilities, demonstrating the need for tailored interventions.
联合国开发计划署(UNDP)采用了一种名为社区对话(CC)的方法,以提高社区在应对健康挑战方面的参与度。社区对话基于保罗·弗莱雷的变革性沟通方法,即社区提出问题并通过讨论批判性地审视他们的日常生活经历。我们采用这种方法,在赞比亚的三个农村地区开展社区关于孕产妇和新生儿健康的讨论,目的是制定社区主导的干预措施。
在三个目标地区举行了60次社区对话,覆盖了总共20个卫生设施。在每个地区有目的地选择社区,以涵盖距离卫生设施不同距离的一系列农村和城郊地区。2014年5月至9月期间,在每个社区进行了四次对话。所有对话都进行了数字录音,随后进行了转录。使用NVivo 10版本进行数据分析。
获得孕产妇保健服务的主要障碍包括地理位置、基础设施有限、知识缺乏、人力资源和基本物资短缺以及男性伴侣参与不足。从需求方来看,信息缺乏和误解,以及从供应方来看,卫生工作者培训不足且态度不佳,直接或间接地对目标地区获得孕产妇保健服务产生了负面影响。20个社区中至少有17个提出了应对这些挑战的解决方案,包括针对安全孕产、计划生育和预防青少年怀孕重要性的有针对性的社区宣传。社区成员和关键利益相关者承诺投入时间和资源,在最少外部支持的情况下应对这些挑战。
我们成功应用社区对话方法,探索了赞比亚三个农村地区的孕产妇健康挑战。社区对话作为一个宣传平台,促进了与社区内关键决策者的直接接触,并在纳入社区意见的同时协调优先事项。所有三个地区普遍缺乏关于安全孕产和计划生育的知识。然而,其他问题是卫生设施特有的,这表明需要量身定制的干预措施。