Batsford Sarah, Ryan Cormac G, Martin Denis J
a School of Health and Social Care , Teesside University , Middlesbrough , UK.
b MSK CATS, South Tyneside NHS Foundation Trust, South Shields , Tyne and Wear , UK.
Physiother Theory Pract. 2017 Mar;33(3):173-183. doi: 10.1080/09593985.2017.1288283. Epub 2017 Mar 1.
The aim of this manuscript was to investigate the effectiveness of conservative therapy for phantom limb pain (PLP). In this systematic review, CINAHL, AMED, the Cochrane database of systematic reviews, PEDro, psychology and behavioral sciences collection, and MEDLINE were systematically searched for appropriate randomized controlled trials (RCTs). Selected papers were assessed for risk of bias, and evidence was graded using the GRADE approach. Twelve RCTs met initial inclusion/exclusion criteria, of which five were of sufficient quality for final inclusion. There is conflicting evidence from two RCTs for the effectiveness of electromagnetic shielding limb liners on pain in the short term. There is limited evidence supporting the effectiveness of both hypnosis in the short term and graded motor imagery (GMI) in the short-to-medium term. Additionally, there is limited evidence that a single session of mirror therapy has no immediate effect on PLP. Limb liner discomfort was the only adverse effect identified. This review identifies a range of conservative therapies, many of which demonstrate preliminary evidence of potential with respect to clinically worthwhile effects above control interventions and few, if any, adverse effects. However, there is a paucity of high-quality evidence upon which to make any firm clinical conclusions.
本手稿的目的是研究保守治疗对幻肢痛(PLP)的有效性。在这项系统评价中,我们系统检索了CINAHL、AMED、Cochrane系统评价数据库、PEDro、心理学与行为科学数据库以及MEDLINE,以查找合适的随机对照试验(RCT)。对入选的论文进行偏倚风险评估,并采用GRADE方法对证据进行分级。12项RCT符合初步纳入/排除标准,其中5项质量足够高,最终被纳入。两项RCT关于电磁屏蔽肢体衬垫在短期内对疼痛有效性的证据相互矛盾。支持催眠在短期内以及分级运动想象(GMI)在中短期内有效性的证据有限。此外,仅有有限的证据表明单次镜像疗法对PLP没有即时效果。肢体衬垫不适是唯一确定的不良反应。本评价确认了一系列保守治疗方法,其中许多方法相对于对照干预措施,在具有临床价值的效果方面显示出潜在的初步证据,且几乎没有不良反应。然而,缺乏高质量证据来得出任何确凿的临床结论。