Puviani Mario, Galloni Chiara, Marchetti Silvia, Sergio Pavone Paolo, Lovati Silvia, Pistone Giuseppe, Caputo Valentina, Tilotta Giovanna, Scarcella Giuseppe, Campione Elena, Diluvio Laura, Garofalo Virginia, Bianchi Luca, Milani Massimo
a Dermatology Clinic , Modena , Italy.
b Sant'Agostino Dermatology Service , Milan , Italy.
Curr Med Res Opin. 2017 Jul;33(7):1255-1259. doi: 10.1080/03007995.2017.1313212. Epub 2017 Apr 20.
Sunscreen protection in subjects with actinic keratosis (AK) is highly recommended to prevent clinical evolution of this in situ skin cancer condition. Use of topical anti-cyclooxygenase drugs such as diclofenac and piroxicam reduces the number of lesions and improves the cancerization field. A film-forming medical device in a cream formulation containing organic and inorganic sun-filters (50+ SPF) and piroxicam 0.8% (ACTX) has shown in a pilot, single-center, open trial to reduce AK lesions improving the cancerization field.
We evaluated in a multicenter, assessor-blinded, 3 month trial the efficacy of ACTX in AK.
A total of 70 subjects with at least three AK lesions on the scalp or face were enrolled after written informed consent. Primary outcomes of the study were the clinical evolution of number of AK lesions on a target zone area and the evolution of dermoscopy features of the target lesion, assessing erythema, scaling, pigmentation, and follicular plug, using a 5 point score (from 0 to 4; maximum score: 16). Lesion count and dermoscopy score were evaluated in a blind fashion assessing digital color high definition coded images. A secondary outcome was the Investigator Global Score (IGS) of clinical evolution of the target area using a 7 point scale from -2 (significantly worse) to +4 (completely cured). IGS was evaluated in an open fashion. Subjects were instructed to apply the cream twice daily on the target area, using one finger-tip unit for the treatment of a 35 cm area.
All but one subject (40 men and 30 women, mean age 73 years) concluded the study period. At baseline the mean (±SD) number of AK lesions in the target area were 7.0 (5.9) with a median value of 5 and the dermoscopy score of the target lesion was 7.0 (2.3) with a median value of 7.0. ACTX treatment reduced AK lesions to 3.2 (2.9), (p = .0001; Wilcoxon Test), representing a 55% relative reduction. Dermoscopy score was reduced to 3.3 (2.6) (p = .0001) (a reduction of 53%). The IGS after ACTX treatment was +1.9 (1.1), with a median of 2.0. A total of 86% of subjects showed a clinical improvement of IGS (≥1) with a very significant/complete clearance (score +3 or +4) in 42% subjects. No change or a worsening of AK lesions was observed in 14% of the subjects. The product was well tolerated. No serious adverse events were reported during the duration of the trial.
In this multicenter, assessor-blinded trial, the use of a film-forming medical device with sun protection and anti-inflammatory actions was effective in reducing AK lesions and improving the dermoscopy aspect of the target lesion in 86% of treated subjects. A head-to-head trial evaluating the efficacy of this medical device in comparison with diclofenac is warranted to establish whether this therapeutic approach could offer additional advantages in term of AK lesion reduction compared to an established topical treatment. (Trial ID: ISRCTN72020277).
强烈建议对光化性角化病(AK)患者进行防晒,以防止这种原位皮肤癌病情的临床进展。使用双氯芬酸和吡罗昔康等局部抗环氧化酶药物可减少病变数量并改善癌化区域。一种乳膏制剂的成膜医疗器械,含有有机和无机防晒剂(防晒系数50+)以及0.8%的吡罗昔康(ACTX),在一项试点单中心开放试验中显示可减少AK病变,改善癌化区域。
我们在一项多中心、评估者盲法的3个月试验中评估了ACTX治疗AK的疗效。
在获得书面知情同意后,共纳入70例头皮或面部至少有三处AK病变的患者。研究的主要结局是目标区域AK病变数量的临床变化以及目标病变的皮肤镜特征变化,采用5分制评分(从0到4;最高分:16分)评估红斑、鳞屑、色素沉着和毛囊堵塞情况。以盲法评估数字彩色高清编码图像来计算病变数量和皮肤镜评分。次要结局是使用-2(明显恶化)至+4(完全治愈)的7分制量表评估目标区域临床变化的研究者整体评分(IGS)。IGS以开放方式评估。指导患者每天在目标区域涂抹两次乳膏,治疗35平方厘米区域使用一个指尖单位的量。
除一名患者外,所有患者(40名男性和30名女性,平均年龄73岁)均完成了研究期。基线时,目标区域AK病变的平均(±标准差)数量为7.0(5.9),中位数为5,目标病变的皮肤镜评分为7.0(2.3),中位数为7.0。ACTX治疗后AK病变减少至3.2(2.9),(p = 0.0001;Wilcoxon检验),相对减少55%。皮肤镜评分降至3.3(2.6)(p = 0.0001)(降低53%)。ACTX治疗后的IGS为+1.9(1.1),中位数为2.0。共有86%的患者IGS显示临床改善(≥1),42%的患者有非常显著/完全清除(评分+3或+4)。14%的患者未观察到AK病变变化或恶化。该产品耐受性良好。试验期间未报告严重不良事件。
在这项多中心、评估者盲法试验中,使用具有防晒和抗炎作用的成膜医疗器械可有效减少AK病变,并使86%的受试患者目标病变的皮肤镜表现得到改善。有必要进行一项对比双氯芬酸评估该医疗器械疗效的直接比较试验,以确定与已确立的局部治疗相比,这种治疗方法在减少AK病变方面是否能提供额外优势。(试验编号:ISRCTN72020277)