Mincarone Pierpaolo, Leo Carlo Giacomo, Sabina Saverio, Sarriá-Santamera Antonio, Taruscio Domenica, Serrano-Aguilar Pedro Guillermo, Kanavos Panos
Institute for Research on Population and Social Policies, URT Brindisi, National Research Council of Italy, Brindisi, Italy.
Public Health Genomics. 2017;20(1):1-8. doi: 10.1159/000464100. Epub 2017 Mar 31.
The pricing and reimbursement policies for pharmaceuticals are relevant to balance timely and equitable access for all patients, financial sustainability, and reward for valuable innovation. The proliferation of high-cost specialty medicines is particularly true in rare diseases (RDs) where the pricing mechanism is characterised by a lack of transparency. This work provides an overall picture of current strategies for the definition of the reimbursed prices of orphan drugs (ODs) and highlights some potential improvements. Current strategies and suggestions are presented along 4 dimensions: (1) comprehensive value assessment, (2) early dialogs among relevant stakeholders, (3) innovative reimbursement approaches, and (4) societal participation in producing ODs. Comprehensive value assessment could be achieved by clarifying the approach of distributive justice to adopt, ensuring a representative participation of stakeholders, and with a broad consideration of value-bearing factors. With respect to early dialogs, cross-border cooperation can be determinant to companies and agencies. The cost-benefit ratio of early dialogs needs to be demonstrated and the "regulatory capture" effect should be monitored. Innovative reimbursement approaches were developed to balance the need for evidence-based decisions with the timely access to innovative drugs. The societal participation in producing ODs needs to be recognised in a collaborating framework where adaptive agreements can be developed with mutual satisfaction. Such agreements could also impact on coverage and reimbursement decisions as additional elements for the determination of a comprehensive societal value of ODs. Further research is needed to investigate the highlighted open challenges so that RDs will not remain, in practical terms, orphan diseases.
药品定价和报销政策对于平衡所有患者及时、公平获得药品的机会、财务可持续性以及对有价值创新的奖励至关重要。高成本专科药物的激增在罕见病中尤为明显,在罕见病领域,定价机制缺乏透明度。这项工作全面介绍了当前孤儿药报销价格定义策略,并强调了一些潜在的改进措施。当前的策略和建议从四个维度提出:(1)综合价值评估,(2)相关利益攸关方之间的早期对话,(3)创新报销方法,以及(4)社会参与孤儿药生产。综合价值评估可以通过明确采用的分配正义方法、确保利益攸关方的代表性参与以及广泛考虑价值承载因素来实现。关于早期对话,跨境合作对公司和机构可能具有决定性意义。需要证明早期对话的成本效益比,并监测“监管俘获”效应。开发创新报销方法是为了在基于证据的决策需求与及时获得创新药物之间取得平衡。在一个可以达成双方都满意的适应性协议的合作框架中,需要认可社会参与孤儿药生产。此类协议还可能影响覆盖范围和报销决策,作为确定孤儿药综合社会价值的额外因素。需要进一步研究以调查所强调的开放性挑战,从而使罕见病在实际中不再成为孤儿病。