Institute of Clinical Psychology and Psychotherapy, Technische Universität Dresden, Dresden, Germany.
Social and Epidemiological Research Department, Center for Addiction and Mental Health, Toronto, Canada.
Int J Methods Psychiatr Res. 2017 Sep;26(3). doi: 10.1002/mpr.1563. Epub 2017 Mar 28.
The quantity and frequency of alcohol consumption are crucial both in risk assessment as well as epidemiological and clinical research. Using the Munich Composite International Diagnostic Interview (M-CIDI), drinking amounts have been assessed in numerous large-scale studies. However, the accuracy of this assessment has rarely been evaluated. This study evaluates the relevance of drink categories and pouring sizes, and the factors used to convert actual drinks into standard drinks. We compare the M-CIDI to alternative drink assessment instruments and empirically validate drink categories using a general population sample (n = 3165 from Germany), primary care samples (n = 322 from Italy, n = 1189 from Germany), and a non-representative set of k = 22503 alcoholic beverages sold in Germany in 2010-2016. The M-CIDI supplement sheet displays more categories than other instruments (AUDIT, TLFB, WHO-CIDI). Beer, wine, and spirits represent the most prevalent categories in the samples. The suggested standard drink conversion factors were inconsistent for different pouring sizes of the same drink and, to a smaller extent, across drink categories. For the use in Germany and Italy, we propose the limiting of drink categories and pouring sizes, and a revision of the proposed standard drinks. We further suggest corresponding examinations and revisions in other cultures.
饮酒量和饮酒频率在风险评估以及流行病学和临床研究中都至关重要。使用慕尼黑复合国际诊断访谈(M-CIDI),在许多大规模研究中评估了饮酒量。然而,这种评估的准确性很少得到评估。本研究评估了饮酒类别和倒酒量的相关性,以及将实际饮酒量转换为标准饮酒量所使用的因素。我们将 M-CIDI 与其他饮料评估工具进行了比较,并使用一般人群样本(来自德国的 n = 3165)、初级保健样本(来自意大利的 n = 322,来自德国的 n = 1189)和 2010-2016 年在德国销售的非代表性 k = 22503 种酒精饮料对饮料类别进行了实证验证。M-CIDI 补充表显示的类别比其他工具(AUDIT、TLFB、WHO-CIDI)多。啤酒、葡萄酒和烈酒是样本中最常见的类别。对于相同饮料的不同倒酒量以及在一定程度上对于不同饮料类别,建议的标准饮酒转换因子并不一致。对于在德国和意大利的使用,我们建议限制饮料类别和倒酒量,并修订建议的标准饮品。我们还建议在其他文化中进行相应的检查和修订。