Baca Christine B, Barry Frances, Vickrey Barbara G, Caplan Rochelle, Berg Anne T
Department of Neurology, University of Colorado Anschutz School of Medicine, Aurora, Colorado, U.S.A.
Department of Neurology, University of California Los Angeles, Los Angeles, California, U.S.A.
Epilepsia. 2017 May;58(5):781-791. doi: 10.1111/epi.13726. Epub 2017 Apr 4.
We aimed to compare long-term social outcomes in young adults with childhood-onset epilepsy (cases) with neurologically normal sibling controls.
Long-term social outcomes were assessed at the 15-year follow-up of the Connecticut Study of Epilepsy, a community-based prospective cohort study of children with newly diagnosed epilepsy. Young adults with childhood-onset epilepsy with complicated (abnormal neurologic exam findings, abnormal brain imaging with lesion referable to epilepsy, intellectual disability (ID; IQ < 60) or informative history of neurologic insults to which the occurrence of epilepsy might be attributed), and uncomplicated epilepsy presentations were compared to healthy sibling controls. Age, gender, and matched-pair adjusted generalized linear models stratified by complicated epilepsy and 5-year seizure-free status estimated adjusted odds ratios (aORs) and 95% confidence intervals [CIs] for each outcome.
The 15-year follow-up included 361 individuals with epilepsy (59% of initial cases; N = 291 uncomplicated and N = 70 complicated epilepsy; mean age 22 years [standard deviation, SD 3.5]; mean epilepsy onset 6.2 years [SD 3.9]) and 173 controls. Social outcomes for cases with uncomplicated epilepsy with ≥5 years terminal remission were comparable to controls; cases with uncomplicated epilepsy <5 years seizure-free were more likely to be less productive (school/employment < 20 h/week) (aOR 3.63, 95% CI 1.83-7.20) and not to have a driver's license (aOR 6.25, 95% CI 2.85-13.72). Complicated cases with epilepsy <5 years seizure-free had worse outcomes across multiple domains; including not graduating high school (aOR 24.97, 95% CI 7.49-83.30), being un- or underemployed (<20 h/week) (aOR 11.06, 95% CI 4.44-27.57), being less productively engaged (aOR 15.71, 95% CI 6.88-35.88), and not living independently (aOR 10.24, 95% CI 3.98-26.36). Complicated cases without ID (N = 36) had worse outcomes with respect to productive engagement (aOR 6.02; 95% CI 2.48-14.58) compared to controls. Cases with complicated epilepsy were less likely to be driving compared to controls, irrespective of remission status or ID.
In individuals with uncomplicated childhood-onset epilepsy presentations and 5-year terminal remission, young adult social outcomes are comparable to those of sibling controls. Complicated epilepsy, notable for intellectual disability, and seizure remission status are important prognostic indicators for long-term young adult social outcomes in childhood-onset epilepsy.
我们旨在比较患有儿童期起病癫痫的年轻成年人(病例组)与神经功能正常的同胞对照的长期社会结局。
在康涅狄格癫痫研究的15年随访中评估长期社会结局,该研究是一项基于社区的新诊断癫痫儿童前瞻性队列研究。将患有复杂型(神经系统检查结果异常、有可归因于癫痫的脑损伤的异常脑成像、智力残疾(ID;智商<60)或有癫痫可能归因的神经系统损伤的信息性病史)和非复杂型癫痫表现的儿童期起病癫痫的年轻成年人与健康同胞对照进行比较。年龄、性别以及按复杂型癫痫和5年无癫痫发作状态分层的配对调整广义线性模型估计了每种结局的调整优势比(aOR)和95%置信区间[CI]。
15年随访包括361例癫痫患者(占初始病例的59%;291例非复杂型癫痫和70例复杂型癫痫;平均年龄22岁[标准差,SD 3.5];平均癫痫发病年龄6.2岁[SD 3.9])和173例对照。无复杂型癫痫且有≥5年最终缓解期的病例的社会结局与对照相当;无复杂型癫痫且癫痫发作少于5年的病例更可能生产力较低(上学/工作<20小时/周)(aOR 3.63,95% CI 1.83 - 7.20)且没有驾照(aOR 6.25,95% CI 2.85 - 13.72)。癫痫发作少于5年的复杂型病例在多个领域结局更差;包括未高中毕业(aOR 24.97,95% CI 7.49 - 83.30)、未就业或就业不足(<20小时/周)(aOR 11.06,95% CI 4. [此处原文有误,应为4.44] - 27.57)、生产力参与度较低(aOR 15.71,95% CI 6.88 - 35.88)以及未独立生活(aOR 10.24,95% CI 3.98 - 26.36)。与对照相比,无ID的复杂型病例(N = 36)在生产力参与方面结局更差(aOR 6.02;95% CI 2.48 - 14.58)。与对照相比,患有复杂型癫痫的病例开车的可能性较小,无论缓解状态或ID如何。
在无复杂型儿童期起病癫痫表现且有5年最终缓解期的个体中,年轻成年人的社会结局与同胞对照相当。以智力残疾为特征的复杂型癫痫和癫痫发作缓解状态是儿童期起病癫痫年轻成年人长期社会结局的重要预后指标。