Lavigne Mikael, Birken Catherine S, Maguire Jonathon L, Straus Sharon, Laupacis Andreas
Department of Pediatrics, North York General Hospital, Toronto, Canada.
Department of Pediatrics, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada.
Arch Dis Child. 2017 Aug;102(8):748-753. doi: 10.1136/archdischild-2016-312284. Epub 2017 Apr 12.
To identify the unanswered research questions in paediatric preventive care that are most important to parents and clinicians, and to explore how questions from parents and clinicians may differ.
Iterative mixed methods research priority setting process.
Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Parents of children aged 0-5 years enrolled in a research network in Toronto, and clinicians practising in Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Informed by the James Lind Alliance's methodology, an online questionnaire collected unanswered research questions in paediatric preventive care from study participants. Similar submissions were combined and ranked. A consensus workshop attended by 28 parents and clinicians considered the most highly ranked submissions and used the nominal group technique to select the 10 most important unanswered research questions.
Forty-two clinicians and 115 parents submitted 255 and 791 research questions, respectively, which were combined into 79 indicative questions. Most submissions were about nutrition, illness prevention, parenting and behaviour management. Parents were more likely to ask questions about screen time (49 parents vs 8 clinicians, p<0.05) and environmental toxins (18 parents vs 0 clinicians, p<0.05). The top 10 unanswered questions identified at the workshop related to mental health, parental stress, physical activity, obesity, childhood development, behaviour management and screen time.
The top 10 most important unanswered research questions in paediatric preventive care from the perspective of parents and clinicians were identified. These research priorities may be important in advancing preventive healthcare for children.
确定儿科预防保健中对家长和临床医生最重要的未解决研究问题,并探讨家长和临床医生提出的问题可能存在的差异。
迭代式混合方法研究优先级设定过程。
加拿大多伦多市安大略省。
多伦多一个研究网络中登记的0至5岁儿童的家长,以及在加拿大多伦多市安大略省执业的临床医生。
根据詹姆斯·林德联盟的方法,通过在线问卷收集研究参与者提出的儿科预防保健方面未解决的研究问题。将类似的提交内容合并并排序。28名家长和临床医生参加了一次共识研讨会,审议了排名最高的提交内容,并使用名义群体技术选出了10个最重要的未解决研究问题。
42名临床医生和115名家长分别提交了255个和791个研究问题,这些问题合并为79个指示性问题。大多数提交内容涉及营养、疾病预防、育儿和行为管理。家长更有可能提出关于屏幕使用时间的问题(49名家长对8名临床医生,p<0.05)和环境毒素问题(18名家长对0名临床医生,p<0.05)。研讨会上确定的前10个未解决问题与心理健康、父母压力、身体活动、肥胖、儿童发育、行为管理和屏幕使用时间有关。
确定了从家长和临床医生角度来看儿科预防保健中最重要的10个未解决研究问题。这些研究重点可能对推进儿童预防保健很重要。