Azar Nabih, Leblond Veronique, Ouzegdouh Maya, Button Paul
Groupe Hospitalier, Pitié Salpêtrière, Paris, France.
ProcEx Solutions Ltd., Wales, United Kingdom.
J Clin Apher. 2017 Dec;32(6):474-478. doi: 10.1002/jca.21542. Epub 2017 Apr 17.
The Pitié Salpêtrière Hospital Hemobiotherapy Department, Paris, France, has been providing extracorporeal photopheresis (ECP) since November 2011, and started using the Therakos CELLEX fully integrated system in 2012. This report summarizes our single-center experience of transitioning from the use of multi-step ECP procedures to the fully integrated ECP system, considering the capacity and cost implications.
The total number of ECP procedures performed 2011-2015 was derived from department records. The time taken to complete a single ECP treatment using a multi-step technique and the fully integrated system at our department was assessed. Resource costs (2014€) were obtained for materials and calculated for personnel time required. Time-driven activity-based costing methods were applied to provide a cost comparison.
The number of ECP treatments per year increased from 225 (2012) to 727 (2015). The single multi-step procedure took 270 min compared to 120 min for the fully integrated system. The total calculated per-session cost of performing ECP using the multi-step procedure was greater than with the CELLEX system (€1,429.37 and €1,264.70 per treatment, respectively).
For hospitals considering a transition from multi-step procedures to fully integrated methods for ECP where cost may be a barrier, time-driven activity-based costing should be utilized to gain a more comprehensive understanding the full benefit that such a transition offers. The example from our department confirmed that there were not just cost and time savings, but that the time efficiencies gained with CELLEX allow for more patient treatments per year.
法国巴黎皮提耶尔-萨尔佩特里埃医院血液治疗科自2011年11月起提供体外光化学疗法(ECP),并于2012年开始使用Therakos CELLEX全集成系统。本报告总结了我们单中心从使用多步骤ECP程序过渡到全集成ECP系统的经验,并考虑了其容量和成本影响。
2011 - 2015年进行的ECP程序总数来自科室记录。评估了在我们科室使用多步骤技术和全集成系统完成单次ECP治疗所需的时间。获取了材料的资源成本(2014欧元),并计算了所需的人员时间成本。应用时间驱动作业成本法进行成本比较。
每年的ECP治疗次数从2012年的225次增加到2015年的727次。单个多步骤程序需要270分钟,而全集成系统只需120分钟。使用多步骤程序进行ECP的每次治疗总计算成本高于CELLEX系统(分别为每次治疗1429.37欧元和1264.70欧元)。
对于考虑从多步骤程序过渡到全集成ECP方法(成本可能是一个障碍)的医院,应采用时间驱动作业成本法,以更全面地了解这种过渡所带来的全部益处。我们科室的例子证实,不仅节省了成本和时间,而且CELLEX系统提高的时间效率使得每年能够治疗更多患者。