Coulson James M, Caparrotta Thomas M, Thompson John P
a National Poisons Information Service (Cardiff) , Cardiff , UK.
Clin Toxicol (Phila). 2017 Jun;55(5):313-321. doi: 10.1080/15563650.2017.1291944. Epub 2017 Feb 20.
Aconite poisoning is relatively rare but is frequently complicated by ventricular dysrhythmias, which may be fatal. Molecular basis of aconite alkaloid ventricular arrhythmogenicity: Aconite exerts its toxic effects due to the presence of an admixture of alkaloids present in all parts of the plant. The major target of these aconite alkaloids is the fast voltage-gates sodium channel, where they cause persistent activation. This blockade of the channel in the activated state promotes automaticity within the ventricular myocardium and the generation of ventricular arrhythmias. Aconitine-induced arrhythmias: Aconite alkaloids are known to cause many different types of disturbance of heart rhythm. However, this focused review specifically looks at ventricular rhythm disturbances, namely ventricular ectopy, ventricular tachycardia, torsades des pointes and ventricular fibrillation.
The objective of this review was to identify the outcome of anti-dysrhythmic strategies from animal studies and case reports in humans in order to guide the management of ventricular dysrhythmias in aconite poisoning in humans.
A review of the literature in English was conducted in PubMed and Google Scholar from 1966 to July 2016 using the search terms "aconite/aconitine"; "aconite/aconitine + poisoning" and "aconite/aconitine + dysrhythmia". 168 human case-reports and case-series were identified by these searches, of which 103 were rejected if exposure to aconite did not result in ventricular dysrhythmias, if it was uncertain as to whether aconite had been ingested, if other agents were co-ingested, if there was insufficient information to determine the type of treatments administered or if there was insufficient information to determine outcome. Thus, 65 case reports of probable aconite poisoning that resulted in ventricular dysrhythmias were identified. Toxicokinetic data in aconite poisoning: Data were only available in three papers; the presence of ventricular rhythm disturbances directly correlated with the concentration of aconite alkaloids in the plasma.
54 of 65 cases developed ventricular tachycardia, six developed torsades des pointes, 15 patients developed ventricular fibrillation, 10 developed ventricular ectopics and one developed a broad complex tachycardia not otherwise specified; each dysrhythmia was regarded as separate and patients may have had more than one dysrhythmia. 10 patients died, giving a mortality of 15%. In total, 147 treatments were administered to 65 patients. 46 of the interventions were assessed by the authors as having been associated with successful restoration of sinus rhythm. Flecainide administration was accompanied by dysrhythmia termination in six of seven cases. Mexiletine was connected with correcting dysrhythmias in 3 of 3 cases. Procainamide administration was associated with return to sinus rhythm in 2 of 2 cases. Prolonged cardio-pulmonary resuscitation was administered to 15 patients where it was associated with a return to sinus rhythm in nine of these. Amiodarone was linked to success in correcting dysrhythmias in 11 of 20 cases. Cardiopulmonary bypass use was associated with a return to sinus rhythm in four out of six cases. Epinephrine was documented as being employed on four occasions, and was associated with a restoration of sinus rhythm on two of these. Magnesium sulphate administration was accompanied by dysrhythmia termination in two of nine cases. Direct cardioversion was associated with a return of sinus rhythm in 5 of 30 cases. However, it is not certain whether the drug treatment influenced the course of the dysrhythmia.
Based on the evidence available from human case reports, flecainaide or amiodarone appear to be more associated with a return to sinus rhythm than lidocaine and/or cardioversion, although it is not established whether the administration of treatment caused reversion to normal sinus rhythm. The potential beneficial effects of amiodarone were not observed in animal studies. This may be due to intra-species differences between ion channels or relate to the wider cardiovascular toxicity of aconite that extends beyond arrhythmias. Prolonged cardiopulmonary resuscitation and cardiopulmonary bypass should be considered as an integral part of good clinical care as "time-buying" strategies to allow the body to excrete the toxic alkaloids. There may also be a role for mexiletine, procainamide and magnesium sulphate.
乌头中毒相对罕见,但常并发室性心律失常,可能致命。乌头生物碱致室性心律失常的分子基础:乌头因其各部位均含有生物碱混合物而产生毒性作用。这些乌头生物碱的主要靶点是快速电压门控钠通道,它们在该通道处导致持续激活。通道在激活状态下的这种阻断促进了心室肌的自律性并引发室性心律失常。乌头碱诱发的心律失常:已知乌头生物碱会引起多种不同类型的心律紊乱。然而,本综述特别关注室性心律紊乱,即室性早搏、室性心动过速、尖端扭转型室速和心室颤动。
本综述的目的是确定动物研究和人类病例报告中抗心律失常策略的结果,以指导人类乌头中毒时室性心律失常的管理。
于2016年7月在PubMed和谷歌学术中使用检索词“乌头/乌头碱”、“乌头/乌头碱+中毒”和“乌头/乌头碱+心律失常”对1966年以来的英文文献进行综述。通过这些检索识别出168篇人类病例报告和病例系列,其中103篇因以下情况被排除:乌头暴露未导致室性心律失常、不确定是否摄入乌头、同时摄入其他药物、确定所给予治疗类型的信息不足或确定结局的信息不足。因此,确定了65例可能的乌头中毒导致室性心律失常的病例报告。乌头中毒的毒代动力学数据:仅有三篇论文提供了相关数据;室性心律紊乱的出现与血浆中乌头生物碱的浓度直接相关。
65例患者中,54例发生室性心动过速,6例发生尖端扭转型室速,15例发生心室颤动,10例发生室性早搏,1例发生未另行特指的宽QRS波心动过速;每种心律失常被视为独立情况,患者可能有不止一种心律失常。10例患者死亡,死亡率为15%。65例患者共接受了147次治疗。作者评估其中46次干预与窦性心律成功恢复相关。氟卡尼治疗的7例中有6例心律失常终止。美西律治疗的3例中有3例纠正了心律失常。普鲁卡因胺治疗的2例中有2例恢复窦性心律。15例患者接受了长时间心肺复苏,其中9例恢复窦性心律。胺碘酮治疗的20例中有11例纠正心律失常成功。6例体外循环治疗的患者中有4例恢复窦性心律。有4次记录使用了肾上腺素,其中2次恢复窦性心律。硫酸镁治疗的9例中有2例心律失常终止。30例直接电复律治疗的患者中有5例恢复窦性心律。然而,不确定药物治疗是否影响了心律失常的病程。
根据人类病例报告的现有证据,氟卡尼或胺碘酮似乎比利多卡因和/或电复律更易使窦性心律恢复,尽管尚未确定治疗的给予是否导致恢复正常窦性心律。在动物研究中未观察到胺碘酮的潜在有益作用。这可能是由于离子通道的种内差异,或与乌头超出心律失常范围的更广泛心血管毒性有关。长时间心肺复苏和体外循环应被视为良好临床护理的组成部分,作为“争取时间”的策略,以使身体排出有毒生物碱。美西律、普鲁卡因胺和硫酸镁可能也有作用。