Capal Jamie K, Bernardino-Cuesta Beatriz, Horn Paul S, Murray Donna, Byars Anna Weber, Bing Nicole M, Kent Bridget, Pearson Deborah A, Sahin Mustafa, Krueger Darcy A
Department of Neurology MLC 2015, Cincinnati Children's Hospital Medical Center, 3333 Burnet Avenue, Cincinnati, OH 45229, USA.
Seccion de Neuropediatria, Hospital Infantil Universitario Nino Jesus, Madrid, Spain.
Epilepsy Behav. 2017 May;70(Pt A):245-252. doi: 10.1016/j.yebeh.2017.02.007. Epub 2017 Apr 28.
Epilepsy is commonly seen in Tuberous Sclerosis Complex (TSC). The relationship between seizures and developmental outcomes has been reported, but few studies have examined this relationship in a prospective, longitudinal manner. The objective of the study was to evaluate the relationship between seizures and early development in TSC.
Analysis of 130 patients ages 0-36months with TSC participating in the TSC Autism Center of Excellence Network, a large multicenter, prospective observational study evaluating biomarkers predictive of autism spectrum disorder (ASD), was performed. Infants were evaluated longitudinally with standardized evaluations, including cognitive, adaptive, and autism-specific measures. Seizure history was collected continuously throughout, including seizure type and frequency.
Data were analyzed at 6, 12, 18, and 24months of age. Patients without a history of seizures performed better on all developmental assessments at all time points compared to patients with a history of seizures and exhibited normal development at 24months. Patients with a history of seizures not only performed worse, but developmental progress lagged behind the group without seizures. All patients with a history of infantile spasms performed worse on all developmental assessments at 12, 18, and 24months. Higher seizure frequency correlated with poorer outcomes on developmental testing at all time points, but particularly at 12months and beyond. Patients with higher seizure frequency during infancy continued to perform worse developmentally through 24months. A logistic model looking at the individual impact of infantile spasms, seizure frequency, and age of seizure onset as predictors of developmental delay revealed that age of seizure onset was the most important factor in determining developmental outcome.
Results of this study further define the relationship between seizures and developmental outcomes in young children with TSC. Early seizure onset in infants with TSC negatively impacts very early neurodevelopment, which persists through 24months of age.
癫痫在结节性硬化症(TSC)中较为常见。癫痫发作与发育结局之间的关系已有报道,但很少有研究以前瞻性、纵向的方式探讨这种关系。本研究的目的是评估TSC中癫痫发作与早期发育之间的关系。
对130例年龄在0至36个月的TSC患者进行分析,这些患者参与了TSC卓越自闭症中心网络研究,这是一项大型多中心前瞻性观察性研究,旨在评估预测自闭症谱系障碍(ASD)的生物标志物。对婴儿进行纵向标准化评估,包括认知、适应性和自闭症特异性测量。在整个过程中持续收集癫痫发作史,包括发作类型和频率。
在6、12、18和24个月龄时对数据进行分析。与有癫痫发作史的患者相比,无癫痫发作史的患者在所有时间点的所有发育评估中表现更好,并且在24个月时发育正常。有癫痫发作史的患者不仅表现更差,而且发育进程落后于无癫痫发作的组。所有有婴儿痉挛病史的患者在12、18和24个月时的所有发育评估中表现更差。癫痫发作频率越高,在所有时间点的发育测试中结局越差,尤其是在12个月及以后。婴儿期癫痫发作频率较高的患者在24个月时的发育仍持续较差。一个逻辑模型将婴儿痉挛、癫痫发作频率和癫痫发作起始年龄作为发育迟缓的预测因素进行个体影响分析,结果显示癫痫发作起始年龄是决定发育结局的最重要因素。
本研究结果进一步明确了TSC幼儿中癫痫发作与发育结局之间的关系。TSC婴儿早期癫痫发作对早期神经发育产生负面影响,并持续至24个月龄。