Jarnes Utz Jeanine R, Kim Sarah, King Kelly, Ziegler Richard, Schema Lynn, Redtree Evelyn S, Whitley Chester B
University of Minnesota, 420 Delaware St SE, MMC 391, Minneapolis, MN 55455-0341, USA; University of Minnesota, Department of Pediatrics, 2450 Riverside Avenue, Minneapolis, MN 55454-1450, USA; University of Minnesota, Department of Experimental and Clinical Pharmacology, College of Pharmacy, 420 Delaware St SE, MMC 446, Minneapolis, MN 55455-0341, USA; Advanced Therapies Program, University of Minnesota (UMMC) and Fairview Hospitals, Minneapolis, MN 55454, USA.
University of Minnesota, College of Pharmacy, 420 Delaware St SE, MMC 391, Minneapolis, MN 55455-0341, USA.
Mol Genet Metab. 2017 Jun;121(2):170-179. doi: 10.1016/j.ymgme.2017.04.011. Epub 2017 Apr 29.
Infantile gangliosidoses include GM1 gangliosidosis and GM2 gangliosidosis (Tay-Sachs disease, Sandhoff disease). To date, natural history studies in infantile GM2 (iGM2) have been retrospective and conducted through surveys. Compared to iGM2, there is even less natural history information available on infantile GM1 disease (iGM1). There are no approved treatments for infantile gangliosidoses. Substrate reduction therapy using miglustat has been tried, but is limited by gastrointestinal side effects. Development of effective treatments will require identification of meaningful outcomes in the setting of rapidly progressive and fatal diseases.
This study aimed to establish a timeline of clinical changes occurring in infantile gangliosidoses, prospectively, to: 1) characterize the natural history of these diseases; 2) improve planning of clinical care; and 3) identify meaningful future treatment outcome measures.
Patients were evaluated prospectively through ongoing clinical care.
Twenty-three patients were evaluated: 8 infantile GM1, 9 infantile Tay-Sachs disease, 6 infantile Sandhoff disease. Common patterns of clinical change included: hypotonia before 6months of age; severe motor skill impairment within first year of life; seizures; dysphagia and feeding-tube placement before 18months of age. Neurodevelopmental testing scores reached the floor of the testing scale by 20 to 28months of age. Vertebral beaking, kyphosis, and scoliosis were unique to patients with infantile GM1. Chest physiotherapy was associated with increased survival in iGM1 (p=0.0056). Miglustat combined with a low-carbohydrate ketogenic diet (the Syner-G regimen) in patients who received a feeding-tube was associated with increased survival in infantile GM1 (p=0.025).
This is the first prospective study of the natural history of infantile gangliosidoses and the very first natural history of infantile GM1. The homogeneity of the infantile gangliosidoses phenotype as demonstrated by the clinical events timeline in this study provides promising secondary outcome measure candidates. This study indicates that overall survival is a meaningful primary outcome measure for future clinical trials due to reliable timing and early occurrence of this event. Combination therapy approaches, instead of monotherapy approaches, will likely be the best way to optimize clinical outcomes. Combination therapy approaches include palliative therapies (e.g., chest physiotherapy) along with treatments that address the underlying disease pathology (e.g. miglustat or future gene therapies).
婴儿期神经节苷脂病包括GM1神经节苷脂病和GM2神经节苷脂病(泰-萨克斯病、桑德霍夫病)。迄今为止,婴儿期GM2神经节苷脂病(iGM2)的自然史研究一直是回顾性的,通过调查进行。与iGM2相比,婴儿期GM1神经节苷脂病(iGM1)的自然史信息更少。婴儿期神经节苷脂病尚无获批的治疗方法。已尝试使用米格列醇进行底物减少疗法,但受胃肠道副作用限制。在快速进展和致命性疾病的背景下,开发有效的治疗方法需要确定有意义的结局指标。
本研究旨在前瞻性地确定婴儿期神经节苷脂病临床变化的时间线,以:1)描述这些疾病的自然史;2)改善临床护理规划;3)确定未来有意义的治疗结局指标。
通过持续的临床护理对患者进行前瞻性评估。
共评估了23例患者:8例婴儿期GM1神经节苷脂病、9例婴儿期泰-萨克斯病、6例婴儿期桑德霍夫病。临床变化的常见模式包括:6个月龄前肌张力低下;1岁内严重运动技能受损;癫痫发作;18个月龄前吞咽困难和放置喂食管。神经发育测试分数在20至28个月龄时降至测试量表的最低值。椎体喙突、脊柱后凸和脊柱侧凸是婴儿期GM1神经节苷脂病患者所特有的。胸部物理治疗与iGM1患者生存率提高相关(p=0.0056)。接受喂食管的患者中,米格列醇联合低碳水化合物生酮饮食(Syner-G方案)与婴儿期GM1神经节苷脂病患者生存率提高相关(p=0.025)。
这是第一项关于婴儿期神经节苷脂病自然史的前瞻性研究,也是第一项关于婴儿期GM1神经节苷脂病的自然史研究。本研究中临床事件时间线所显示的婴儿期神经节苷脂病表型的同质性提供了有前景的次要结局指标候选者。本研究表明,由于该事件发生时间可靠且较早出现,总体生存率是未来临床试验中有意义的主要结局指标。联合治疗方法而非单一治疗方法可能是优化临床结局的最佳途径。联合治疗方法包括姑息治疗(如胸部物理治疗)以及针对潜在疾病病理的治疗(如米格列醇或未来的基因治疗)。