Burgard Sarah, Castiglione Debora de Pina, Lin Katherine Y, Nobre Aline A, Aquino Estela M L, Pereira Alexandre C, Bensenor Isabela J Martins, Barreto Sandhi M, Chor Dora
Department of Sociology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, U.S.A.
Escola Nacional de Saúde Pública Sergio Arouca, Fundação Oswaldo Cruz, Rio de Janeiro, Brasil.
Cad Saude Publica. 2017 May 8;33Suppl 1(Suppl 1):e00110516. doi: 10.1590/0102-311X00110516.
There has been little cross-national comparison of perceived discrimination, and few studies have considered how intersectional identities shape perception of discriminatory treatment in different societies. Using data from the ELSA-Brasil, a study of Brazilian civil servants, and the Americans' Changing Lives Study, a nationally-representative sample of U.S. adults, we compare reports of lifetime discrimination among race-by-gender groups in each society. We also consider whether educational attainment explains any group differences, or if differences across groups vary by level of education. Results reveal higher lifetime discrimination experiences among Black respondents in both countries, especially Black men, than among Whites, and lower reports among White women than White men. Brown men and women also reported higher levels than White men in Brazil. For all race-by-gender groups in both countries, except Brazilian White men, reports of discrimination were higher among the more educated, though adjusting for educational differences across groups did not explain group differences. In Brazil, we found the greatest racial disparities among the college educated, while U.S. Black men were more likely to report discrimination than White men at all levels of education. Results reveal broad similarities across countries, despite important differences in their histories, and an intersectional approach contributed to identification of these similarities and some differences in discrimination experiences. These findings have implications for social and public health surveillance and intervention to address the harmful consequences of discrimination.
对于感知到的歧视,跨国比较很少,而且很少有研究考虑交叉身份如何塑造不同社会中对歧视性待遇的认知。利用来自巴西公务员研究ELSA - Brasil以及美国成年人全国代表性样本“美国人生活变化研究”的数据,我们比较了每个社会中按种族和性别分组的终身歧视报告。我们还考虑教育程度是否能解释任何群体差异,或者不同群体之间的差异是否因教育水平而异。结果显示,两国的黑人受访者,尤其是黑人男性,一生经历的歧视比白人更多,而白人女性的报告比白人男性更低。在巴西,棕色人种的男性和女性报告的歧视水平也高于白人男性。在两国所有按种族和性别的群体中,除了巴西白人男性,受教育程度较高者的歧视报告更多,不过对群体间教育差异进行调整并不能解释群体差异。在巴西,我们发现受过大学教育的人群中种族差异最大,而在美国,所有教育水平下黑人男性比白人男性更有可能报告受到歧视。结果显示,尽管两国历史存在重要差异,但仍有广泛的相似之处,而且交叉性方法有助于识别这些相似之处以及歧视经历中的一些差异。这些发现对社会和公共卫生监测及干预以应对歧视的有害后果具有启示意义。